Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geoffrey G's avatar

This essay is full of sloppy generalizations and far below your best, Noah. It sounds like you’re addressing your friend group as your rhetorical “we,” not Millennials, writ large.

Because how could this “we” be the generation you’re ostensibly talking about and for? Most Millennials didn’t go to college at all, much less overpay for it. Only 38% has a four-year degree! This is part of the general tendency of the (highly-educated) media class to project their own experience too much.

Most Millennials didn’t flirt with Bernie or Socialism or whatever. Only a very modest majority of Millennials even voted in that election--still a much lower rate than for older generations. The boring truth is that most Millennials were like most Americans: relatively politically apathetic and disengaged from the process beyond (maybe) voting.

So what about all the other generalizations and revisionist counter-generalizations here? Are most Millennials living in a house with a two-car garage that they own? This is clearly incorrect since only barely over half of Millennials owns a house, and many of those houses, presumably, look a little different than the TV family homes you’re imagining. This also elides the fact that 49% of Millennials doesn’t own a home at all!

This isn’t a matter of nitpicking or nuance. You’ve totally obscured the reality for Millennials, not to mention the American population as a whole, adding to the general tendency of American media to assume that upper middle class Americans are normative, instead of a minority.

Expand full comment
Mark Tercek's avatar

If student debt can’t be cancelled, how about improving it so that it’s terms are not so rigid and - I think - unfair to borrowers. Just make it more like conventional debt. When interest falls, let borrowers refinance. If borrower is overwhelmed, let chapter 11 address the challenge. Etc

Expand full comment
260 more comments...

No posts