When I first saw this in my inbox this morning (over coffee, in London, where I've come to really appreciate just how great of a nation the US is) I was like, 'oh hell no, they're coming for us'
The reality is, the United States is the first country in arguably the modern world that has had to deal with citizens not looking like each other and, by extension, the very specific problem of citizens looking at each other and not being to immediately know "hey that is my fellow citizen."
This is not a bad problem. This is not a racist problem. We should have empathy for this problem.
When I wrote my book on South Asian American assimilation, HERE TO STAY, I got criticism from the (far) left that it was too pro-America, that the whole idea of multicultural identity that American public schools (atleast in the Northeast, where I'm from) fed had to be deconstructed.
I disagreed and thought that idea was dangerous. It still is. It's what led to the racist and (frankly) dumb reaction from Bo French and that ilk. But it's a fair point that American identity can't be based (only on) multiculturalism. It need to be based on our ideals. And what I learned reporting for HERE TO STAY, is that we all kinda want the same things 1) do right for ourselves 2) do right for our families 3) do right for our communities. America has, and always will be, the best place to do this for the most people.
The reality is that since the post-war era we have been creating an American identity that racists (on the right AND left) will hate because it's note a race-based identity and that the woke will hate because it's pro America.
I'm optimistic, as long as we continue to protect the creation of this new American identity, an identity grounded in our ideals.
the best thing about the US, is that anyone can be American.
It makes me sad that the right wing today thinks that only some people can be Americans.
It should be that anyone that accepts American values as their own, participates, and lives there *is* American. That's it. You can be a recent Chinese immigrant barely speaking English, a hillbilly, or an educated Indian doctor - do you love what America stands for? You want to be part of it? You contribute? You're in!
And then there are the minor but much appreciated elements like the fantastic food folks bring. Imagine American dining choices if we left out kung pao chicken, guacamole, Thai curries or Indian dals. We'd all die young of boredom. I live in a great big city with all kinds of ethnic groups, we even have a large Rohingya population these days. I love it.
Our country proves to the world that immigrants who are often at each other's throats back home get along just fine here along Devon Ave. or Jackson Heights or all kinds of places in LA, Dallas, etc. More please.
Not sure how many Europeans "want to assimilate and be American," as you put it.
But intermarriage rates, which I'm going to use as a proxy for assimilation, are 17% in the US, 9% in UK, 15% in France and 9% in Germany. So, lower than the US (except France, which is not meaningfully different), but non-negligible.
Excellent post. I _finally_ understand what Noah's flavor of liberalism means, and why he is so scornful of the 'woke' project.
I can get behind his plan... ethnogenesis (and abundance) 100%.
The appeal of the 'woke project' was to me a matter of historical truth. It required holding two beliefs in ones head at the same time: (1) That the 'American Experiment' has been a very great good for both Americans and the world since the 18th century and (2) that the US was built to a significant extent on the back of slaves before 1860 and from 1860-1960 engaged in open ethnic cleansing against blacks.
I can hold both of those ideas in my head at the same time, but perhaps many of my fellow Americans simply cannot. They HAVE to pick one truth to be more important than the other.
I think this IS the tension between the left and the right today... do we force ourselves to pick just one idea, presumably (1) to be good American (conservative) or can we accept BOTH ideas at the same time, and do BOTH the ethnogenesis that Noah wants and ALSO stamp out racism at the same time (which also seems to be Noah's interest). Noah would likely argue that the 'woke left' went to far to embrace idea (2) while forgetting (1), and I have to agree with that.
I get it now. Many Americans cannot accept the cognitive dissonance of holding those two ideas at the same time. By acknowledging the historical fact (2), we lose the majority we need for the larger ethnogenesis project. Both by some clinging to (1) and denying (2) and others embracing (2) and denying (1)
IOW, (2) might be good history, but cognitive dissonance is not good politics!
Not only that, they keep talking a big talk about being “inclusive” while excluding anyone who disagrees with them about anything. That’s not actually inclusive.
We can’t unite the country around woke ideology, because some people are conservative and they’re not going away anytime soon, and most whites aren’t ever going to be interested in a system that discriminates against them.
It’s time to rediscover negotiation, compromise, and equal citizenship under law.
Nothing the left ever does has anything to do with historical truth. They are demanding special rights and privileges over other citizens and using this so called "historical truth" as justification.
Sorry, man, but this is plainly untrue and probably just frustration talking. The Left is too obsessed with historical truth to see the forest for the trees and they can't see how things have changed etc.
The problem with focusing so much attention on your idea #2 above is that this isn't the United States of 1960, 1975 or even 2000. Despite Trump's skill at filling his administration with unreconstructed racists and other hopeless reprobates(1), this is a *much* less racist country than it was 20-25 years ago. Not perfect, perhaps never perfect, but better.
And there's a real cost to pretending otherwise, and telling kids that their future here is hopelessly compromised by pervasive racism. I could have been raised that way, being half Turkish, and Jewish as well. But my parents and especially my (Turkish immigrant) father thought that this was the greatest country to live in, with more opportunities than anywhere else.
And so I didn't grow up blaming antisemitism and the like for the inevitable setbacks that everyone encounters in life, and it let me take risks without fearing that I'd fail because everyone with any power would be out to get me.
Footnote(1) -- despite the above, it is amazing how Trump managed to find the absolute biggest pile of losers, idiots and true racists to populate his administration.
No time to dig up citations, but many people on the far right claim racial homogeneity is better because you have greater national unity. One big thing they miss is research showing that a diversity of races and cultures creates greater creativity and diversification. This definitely seems true to me. Having engineers from China, India, Europe,... really brings perspectives and creativity of a type you will not find in homogeneous cultures. And, I'm sure Noah can attest to this from his academic experience. Imagine the US without the 40% of Nobel Prize winners who are first generation immigrants, people like Albert Einstein and Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar.
Sounds like a load of crap to me. If any of that were true, how could China ever compete with its lack of the all important cultural diversity? Immigration and assimilation is an advantage in that it brings in more bodies and nothing more.
China has four times the population of the United States, and it still produces less Nobel prize winners and top line research, and I would say that the research does make sense to me. The United States is more creative. And China is also vastly poorer per capita. You really think the United States will be richer and stronger without people like Einstein and Oppenheimer? You really think we would be richer and stronger without all of those top engineers from India? Try thinking about it.
Chinese research culture is just bad. This is almost certainly related to Chinese culture being way more hierarchical than American culture. And that's not even getting into how the Communist Party can distort research priorities and inquiries.
Ethnic and especially racial diversity has nothing to with scientific discoveries. If it did why were almost all major advances post Scientific Revolution up to the 21st century made by European or American White men?
Diversity probably played a role in that competition between European countries stimulated innovation but racial diversity within those countries clearly didn't matter.
Hunt and Gauthier-Loiselle’s 2010 American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics paper, How Much Does Immigration Boost Innovation?, finds that college-educated immigrants patent at roughly twice the rate of college-educated native born Americans.
Their historical state-level analysis estimates that a one-percentage-point increase in college-educated immigrants’ share of the total population increases patents per capita by approximately 9–18%
An enormous amount of our scientific and technical advance came from Indian and Chinese scientists, engineers, economists, and managers, as well as contributions from Jews like Einstein and Von Neumann. We would be much poor and weaker without these people.
“The Contribution of High-Skilled Immigrants to Innovation in the United States”, currently listed as forthcoming in the American Economic Review, finds that immigrants constitute 16% of inventors but produce 23% of patents in its data.
There are pros and cons to diversity. If the ethnic groups are determined to kill each other and hate each other, and they don’t believe in democracy and human rights, then you just may have to separate them. But the United States at least used to be better than that. And if you are better than that, then you can benefit greatly by attracting the world‘s best, like all those top engineers and scientists from India, and you can really utilize their talents to make you richer, stronger, and safer, and you can actually enjoy other cultures. You can actually enjoy things like eating at Indian restaurants, or going to an Indian wedding, which is a fantastic time.
China has 56 different ethnic groups, although over 90% are Han, but the PRC practices diversification by stealing IP from lots of different countries.
There is some minor evidence for viewpoint diversity improving outcomes, but a) that is only weakly/indirectly tied to diversity in the race/ethnicity sense, and b) the benefit is statistically minimal.
The research on this from the last 15-20 years was wildly overstated. Shocking, I know.
Argentina, a country I know very well, is a great example of non-forced national identity creation. It has at least as many immigrants as the US, from all over the world, that have come in various waves. Yet everyone thinks of herself as Argentinian. They share a certain way of life and are very proud of their country but at the same time, in their homes, they also maintain their original culture and traditions. A German family will observe German traditions, an Italian family Italian ones, same for the English, Spanish, Syrian, Polish etc. Some more, some less, but when you get invited to people’s homes you see it very clearly. But it in no way conflicts with being an Argentinian as well.
Didn’t Argentinian football fans make a chant mocking the French team for having black players and implying they were not French? And then the actual team sang this song the next tournament when they weren’t even playing France?
"We both basically subscribe to the principle of nationalism — we believe that nation-states are exclusive clubs that exist for the benefit of their members, and that this is a basically good way to organize human society."
It should be stressed that any good family or club still cares about human beings outside of their group, and still treats them ethically and fairly, and still provides help to those less fortunate outside their group. Every good family I know donates some money or time or effort to help others in need outside the family.
And I should add that a family, or country, with friends and allies is much better off and more secure than one made in the image of Trump and his party, a hated bully, whose word means nothing, who can never have any true friends.
Amen Noah. I’m a conservative, but you are exactly right. Liberalism rightly understood is a big tent - traditional conservatives and liberals are always going to have policy disagreements, but we have far more in common than the rightists and far left that embrace different flavors of racial identitarianism. Keep up the good fight.
I don’t think we need a shared American ethnicity, what we need is a strong sense of shared American *citizenship*. The one basis on which we can unite our racially, ethnically, and religiously diverse country is around our shared membership in the civic identity of the United States, of equal citizenship under law. This is the umbrella under which all else is gathered.
We also need to rediscover a sense of what shared citizenship means. It means not treating each other as enemies even when we disagree. It means talking over and debating differences of opinion, a political process centered on negotiation and compromise, and a willingness to accept election results and policy outcomes that reflect the will of the majority even when you don’t personally agree. This is the way out of our current mess: remembering that we’re all in this together and we need to be good to each other.
What amazes me is how much all of this sounds just like Norman Tebbit's 1990 "cricket test" in the UK, and how it targets the same people. Back then, the idea was that British Indians who supported the Indian cricket team and not the England one were sufficiently not-integrated. Now you have something very similar-sounding with college football and whatnot in the US. In both cases, it suggests that the person making the argument just doesn't like Indians, and has no better reason not to like them than that.
It's all the more striking because, back then, British Indians were pretty well-integrated by most reasonable-sounding measures, like Indian-Americans are now. They spoke English well, had generally high educational and professional attainment, observed British laws, participated in electoral politics, and so forth. Those comments, like these ones, come across as goalpost-shifting with the specific intent of denying people access to your national, social, or political community.
Great column. And you're absolutely right that the Right will self-destruct as it tries to the country up by ethnic group, ironically the very thing that the Right accuses the Left of doing with DEI and arguments about white privilege. I guess this is an example of the Horseshoe Principle, where extremists on both sides of an issue increasingly resemble one another.
And I do have to wonder about the utter obliviousness of someone who's Jewish allying himself with neo-Nazis like Bo French to argue that people from India can't assimilate in the US. I mean, how long does he think it will be before these folks turn on him?
My mother, born in 1909 to German immigrants, didn't speak English till she went to school & was beaten up by native English speakers every time she opened her mouth. I know she knew German, but I never heard her speak it, & I never heard her parents speak German, either. I find that very sad. I live in a neighborhood full of immigrants from Central America, Nigeria, Eritrea, Ethiopia, & Vietnam, & every damn one is assimilating. Many are much more patriotic than I am, & I'm a VN war vet. It's sad to see fear & loathing of Indian Americans. We should do better.
Noah, I have talked about it before also but the absolute batshit insane dehumanizing rhetoric against Indians is tiring and so harmful for mental health (all social media is a cesspool of vitriol). This is also spilling over as hate crimes in various parts of the world. Even in your comment section I regularly see posters where supposedly reasonable criticism of India quickly slides into contempt and borderline racist (basically racism hidden as good PR)
The greatest irony here is that: Trump is turning out to be a great nation-builder for India. US’s great advantage has been its ability to attract the cream of crop from all over the world and then accumulating and compounding. Making those people feel permanently unwelcome is an amazing way to squander that advantage. And that is happening just as building a life and career in India is becoming an attractive proposition. Sure all industries still don’t pay equally but in tech already the reason to move to US right now considering all this is decreasing by the day. (And this should rejoice the racists). But other industries are also catching up.
I go to quite a few startup meet-ups and events in Bengaluru. Anecdotally speaking, I have met a lot of people in 20s and 30s who want to now stay and build, alongside people who are returning with experience, savings and professional networks. Those people are able to find co-founders, hire others and make starting more attractive for the next person.
On the infra side, India has been accumulating the foundations for this: highways and freight infrastructure, digital payments, a more integrated domestic market, and successive improvements to incorporation, approvals and taxation. Big reforms and hundreds of smaller changes gradually reinforce one another. For a growing cohort, there is now enough opportunity and capital at home to make staying a serious, ambitious choice. We’re entering a sustained period in which more of these pieces come together. We are also regularly posting growth rates north of 7% comfortably almost every quarter now.
The predictable response will be “Where are the results?” These things take years to emerge. My bet is that six or seven years from now, we’ll see significant companies whose founding teams came together here partly because staying or returning made more sense today.
There is real short-term pain for people whose opportunities are being closed off. But I’m increasingly optimistic about the long-term benefit for India. Racists will get fewer Indians arriving, while helping concentrate more talent, ambition and company-building here. US spent generations making itself the place where the world’s ambitious people wanted to build. India has every reason to make the most of America forgetting how valuable that was.
India’s capital markets are also deepening massively: mutual fund assets grew from ₹15.63T ($162B) in August 2016 to ₹87.08T ($900B) in August 2026, while automatic monthly contributions to mutual funds rose from ₹35B ($0.36B) to ₹323B ($3.34B) more than 9x, with all dollar equivalents at today’s exchange rate. Compared with China’s more state-directed allocation of credit, I think this growing role for household savings and commercially allocated capital is a more durable path. Sure, the Indian state cannot redirect enormous sums toward "state objectives" at the same speed. But deeper domestic investment pools give businesses more financing options and room to grow, with decisions spread across investors and institutions. Combined with improving infrastructure and talent staying back, I expect the effects of this accumulation to become increasingly visible sooner than many skeptics imagine.
Make America White Again is not going to happen, ever.
How many Europeans actually want to emigrate to America today? Few.
Most emigrants emigrate for opportunity; America provides that, but so do most European countries. What we should do is be more selective, but that selection should not be based on ethnicity, race, or religion.
Currently, the most successful emigrant groups are the South Asian people from India. They have skills and education. Because they carry the culture of education within them, their offspring will also be successful.
My family's primary care physician is Chinese, my allergist is Chinese, my cardiologist is Indian, a surgeon is Indian, my urologist is a white American, and my ophthalmologist is a white American. As you can see, mostly first- or second-generation immigrants.
Do you want to know why? If you walk through an urban coastal city's hospital, I guarantee you’ll see a slew of Asians and Indians. They are the ones who are willing to take Physics and Chemistry courses in college and are willing to go through schooling and training that can take up to 12 years. Americans are less and less willing to do so.
Take a look at the silicon valley CEO’s; you can smell the butter chicken masala just by reading their names.
This MAGA hatred of Indians is unfounded. America needs smart and hard-working immigrants.
The thinking that more Americans should study STEM and have more children is simply wishful thinking. We have become a lazy, stupid nation filled with nativists a dumb ass bubba’s who think we’re going to go back to the 1950s.
Actually, it is more likely we will end up as Britian, incapable of anything approaching its former greatness.
Well, I don't think we're any more lazy than we used to be. And (being a computer programmer by profession) I suspect that the reason Americans don't take up STEM more is comparative advantage -- it's easier for someone growing up in China to get into a US college, study STEM, get a job here, and thrive at it that it is for them to study business, get an MBA, and get a job on Wall Street. The people growing up in this culture will tend to sort into jobs that reward cultural knowledge and fit. And certainly, here in the US we're really, really good at doing things that make money. (Whereas the UK's GDP/capita is barely growing.)
> Make America White Again is not going to happen, ever.
Heh! I just checked, and Google says the US population was about 20% black in 1776. And that was before the cotton gin, when cotton farming was unprofitable enough that the Founders thought that slavery would die out due to economic considerations.
Indeed, one way to undermine the ethonationalists is to point out that ethnonationalism is un-American. (A charge that will get under their skin.) The US has never been ethnically homogeneous, either in our terms or as people saw it at the time. And while the immigration laws have often barred specific ethnicities/nationalities, they've never been oriented toward allowing only a certain ethnicity to enter. For instance, during the tight immigration years 1920 to 1965, people from Africa were barred, but there were few restrictions on people from the Caribbean, no matter how dark-skinned. And while Chinese were blanket forbidden overall, Chinese who could cook Chinese styles were admitted as "workers with specialized skills". (There's a reason that Chinese restaurants became a cultural trend!)
True, but the American culture did not include different races. It was not socially or ethnically diverse. Funny enough the stories of slaves that ended up in Britian and became successful are legend
"How many Europeans actually want to emigrate to America today? Few."
I don't think that's true at all. I'm sure there are millions and millions of them. America is MUCH richer than most of Europe. Per Capita GDP is about 50% higher in America than Germany
Most immigrants in Europe would come from countries with a far higher social safety net. Sure, some Brits, a few Germans so Dutch. But to get the numbers that MAGA would like, it would take several hundred thousand. I just don’t think there are that many.
Most of America’s immigrants come here for opportunity that doesn’t exist in their country. But hey I am open to it. But that is not where we are going to find the numbers we need to offset the dramatic fall in birth rates.
As far as I can tell from the commentators, the number of people who migrate from Europe to the US is small, as is the number migrating the other way. Partly it's because the GDP/capita difference is compensated by the better safety net, but I think the major factor is that the GDP/capita ratio is only on the order of 2, and that's not enough to drive people to uproot themselves. But there are a lot of countries where the GDP/capita ratio is near 10... and even then, only a fairly small minority are willing to migrate.
"Do you want to know why? If you walk through an urban coastal city's hospital, **I guarantee you’ll see a slew of Asians and Indians**. They are the ones who are willing to take Physics and Chemistry courses in college and are willing to go through schooling and training that can take up to 12 years. Americans are less and less willing to do so."
I see a fellow watcher of Hasan Hates Ronny | Ronny Hates Hasan in the comments section here
Ronny Chieng and Hasan Minhaj from The Daily Show did a joint comedy tour earlier this year on AAPI sociology, and how the sociocultural divide between the Subcontinental diaspora and the diaspora from countries further east plays out in the US. Your observation on the heavy presence of 1st, 1.5, and 2nd gen Asian Americans (both East/Southeast and South) in healthcare is spot on, although depending on where in the US you are this also extends to their African counterparts.
During my last 10 years of work, I was a part-time paramedic in NJ. I retired about 4 years ago. I can safely say their observation is 100% spot on.
I seriously do not understand how they generate any controversy, but I also feel that way about Jews, and they seem to get the whole world hating them.
Increasingly hispanics in the US identify as "white", largely during a period in which purposeful ethnogenesis has been on the backburner.
Why? Ethnogenesis is a largely organic, not imposed process. As it was in the US for the Germans and Irish.
Coincidentally, the hispanic shift is also why the US will remain "majority white", a delicious irony for the New Right xenophobes.
They'll lose their minds when "Indian Americans" start considering themselves "white" too.
It's interesting to contrast all this with Canada. Canada didn't develop much of a "white" identity, perhaps because it's primary historical cleavage was (and arguably remains) language. Instead, the successful ethnogeneses are "Canadian" and "Quebecois". I believe this is why 2nd gen+ immigrants from India are more likely to identify as "Canadian" than "Indian Americans" identify as "American" (or "white").
Hispanics in the US identify as White because White-Hispanic intermarriage is extremely common. Many Hispanics (even very brown ones) are 1/8 or 1/4 European genetically.
You are correct that the Hispanic migration that right wingers hate is ironically what will keep the US majority Christian and White till at least 2100.
Some Indians like Nikki Haley look pretty White because they are 1/3 proto Indo European.
Though I've read that a considerable number of dark-skinned Indian-American kids are calling themselves black. Though my impression is that that is in fairly affluent places with low anti-black sentiment (and current pop culture can easily portray being black as cooler than being white). I don't know what American Blacks think of this...
First Kudos to Noah for taking on this issue by debating Lomez. It’s clear where Noah stands on this question, I just think that his framework leaves some important elements out.
First I found Noah’s conceding that Lomez favoring national cohesion despite his not being a liberal to be an odd concession to make. Conservatives and the far right have never been opposed to national cohesion, they just believe that certain groups need to be excluded from full participation in American society and civic life, or at the very least be marginalized to some degree, in order for national cohesion to be realized. Bo French isn’t anti-national cohesion. He just doesn’t see any path towards national cohesion that includes people of South Asian ancestry and culture, no matter how well they assimilate. And presumably Lomez agrees, he maybe just wouldn’t have gone public with a Tweet expressing his sentiments the way that French did.
And I also scratched my head a bit when Noah referred to Robeson’s song “Ballad for Americans.” It is indeed a beautiful song but to suggest that it reflected the mood of the time is inaccurate to say the least. Robeson himself would have his passport stripped away just a decade later, and in 1940 de jure segregation was still locked in place across the South and de facto segregation held in many other parts of the country. What Robeson represented was a tradition that went back to Douglass, Sumner, Stevens, and others which was an insistence that America live out the ideals laid out in the Declaration and other founding documents. It was an insistence that never chose to forget the past but also refused to be bound by it.
So if we’re to “Pick up the discarded project of our 20th century forebears,” it is indeed people like Robeson whom we should be invoking, but probably not so much FDR, Truman, and LBJ. Those three were reacting to agitation from people like Robeson, A Philip Randolph (who threatened a march on Washington in 1941 that led to FDR banning racial discrimination in defense industries and then a draft-resistance campaign in 1948 that helped push Truman to desegregate the military), and Rustin who organized the 1963 march on Washington.
I also wish Noah had pressed Lomez on his "hazing" framing. Second-generation Indian Americans aren't applicants, they're citizens by birth. Why should any citizen have to endure hazing to enjoy full citizenship? That same logic is behind the current push to reinterpret birthright citizenship, and I'd be curious whether Noah sees that as something to debate and compromise on, or something to reject outright.
So I agree with Noah that we need to continue and build on the incomplete work that our forebears started. But that requires us accurately remembering and understanding just what that work looked like, and why it was necessary.
I'm a longtime listener, first time caller.
When I first saw this in my inbox this morning (over coffee, in London, where I've come to really appreciate just how great of a nation the US is) I was like, 'oh hell no, they're coming for us'
The reality is, the United States is the first country in arguably the modern world that has had to deal with citizens not looking like each other and, by extension, the very specific problem of citizens looking at each other and not being to immediately know "hey that is my fellow citizen."
This is not a bad problem. This is not a racist problem. We should have empathy for this problem.
When I wrote my book on South Asian American assimilation, HERE TO STAY, I got criticism from the (far) left that it was too pro-America, that the whole idea of multicultural identity that American public schools (atleast in the Northeast, where I'm from) fed had to be deconstructed.
I disagreed and thought that idea was dangerous. It still is. It's what led to the racist and (frankly) dumb reaction from Bo French and that ilk. But it's a fair point that American identity can't be based (only on) multiculturalism. It need to be based on our ideals. And what I learned reporting for HERE TO STAY, is that we all kinda want the same things 1) do right for ourselves 2) do right for our families 3) do right for our communities. America has, and always will be, the best place to do this for the most people.
The reality is that since the post-war era we have been creating an American identity that racists (on the right AND left) will hate because it's note a race-based identity and that the woke will hate because it's pro America.
I'm optimistic, as long as we continue to protect the creation of this new American identity, an identity grounded in our ideals.
Can you say more about appreciating the US from London? I'm curious about your perspective there.
the best thing about the US, is that anyone can be American.
It makes me sad that the right wing today thinks that only some people can be Americans.
It should be that anyone that accepts American values as their own, participates, and lives there *is* American. That's it. You can be a recent Chinese immigrant barely speaking English, a hillbilly, or an educated Indian doctor - do you love what America stands for? You want to be part of it? You contribute? You're in!
And then there are the minor but much appreciated elements like the fantastic food folks bring. Imagine American dining choices if we left out kung pao chicken, guacamole, Thai curries or Indian dals. We'd all die young of boredom. I live in a great big city with all kinds of ethnic groups, we even have a large Rohingya population these days. I love it.
Our country proves to the world that immigrants who are often at each other's throats back home get along just fine here along Devon Ave. or Jackson Heights or all kinds of places in LA, Dallas, etc. More please.
agreed, but we should be making sure the people we invite in want to assimilate and be American
Pretty much everyone manages to assimilate in a generation.
Not in Europe
Not sure how many Europeans "want to assimilate and be American," as you put it.
But intermarriage rates, which I'm going to use as a proxy for assimilation, are 17% in the US, 9% in UK, 15% in France and 9% in Germany. So, lower than the US (except France, which is not meaningfully different), but non-negligible.
Excellent post. I _finally_ understand what Noah's flavor of liberalism means, and why he is so scornful of the 'woke' project.
I can get behind his plan... ethnogenesis (and abundance) 100%.
The appeal of the 'woke project' was to me a matter of historical truth. It required holding two beliefs in ones head at the same time: (1) That the 'American Experiment' has been a very great good for both Americans and the world since the 18th century and (2) that the US was built to a significant extent on the back of slaves before 1860 and from 1860-1960 engaged in open ethnic cleansing against blacks.
I can hold both of those ideas in my head at the same time, but perhaps many of my fellow Americans simply cannot. They HAVE to pick one truth to be more important than the other.
I think this IS the tension between the left and the right today... do we force ourselves to pick just one idea, presumably (1) to be good American (conservative) or can we accept BOTH ideas at the same time, and do BOTH the ethnogenesis that Noah wants and ALSO stamp out racism at the same time (which also seems to be Noah's interest). Noah would likely argue that the 'woke left' went to far to embrace idea (2) while forgetting (1), and I have to agree with that.
I get it now. Many Americans cannot accept the cognitive dissonance of holding those two ideas at the same time. By acknowledging the historical fact (2), we lose the majority we need for the larger ethnogenesis project. Both by some clinging to (1) and denying (2) and others embracing (2) and denying (1)
IOW, (2) might be good history, but cognitive dissonance is not good politics!
Not only that, they keep talking a big talk about being “inclusive” while excluding anyone who disagrees with them about anything. That’s not actually inclusive.
We can’t unite the country around woke ideology, because some people are conservative and they’re not going away anytime soon, and most whites aren’t ever going to be interested in a system that discriminates against them.
It’s time to rediscover negotiation, compromise, and equal citizenship under law.
Nothing the left ever does has anything to do with historical truth. They are demanding special rights and privileges over other citizens and using this so called "historical truth" as justification.
Sorry, man, but this is plainly untrue and probably just frustration talking. The Left is too obsessed with historical truth to see the forest for the trees and they can't see how things have changed etc.
The problem with focusing so much attention on your idea #2 above is that this isn't the United States of 1960, 1975 or even 2000. Despite Trump's skill at filling his administration with unreconstructed racists and other hopeless reprobates(1), this is a *much* less racist country than it was 20-25 years ago. Not perfect, perhaps never perfect, but better.
And there's a real cost to pretending otherwise, and telling kids that their future here is hopelessly compromised by pervasive racism. I could have been raised that way, being half Turkish, and Jewish as well. But my parents and especially my (Turkish immigrant) father thought that this was the greatest country to live in, with more opportunities than anywhere else.
And so I didn't grow up blaming antisemitism and the like for the inevitable setbacks that everyone encounters in life, and it let me take risks without fearing that I'd fail because everyone with any power would be out to get me.
Footnote(1) -- despite the above, it is amazing how Trump managed to find the absolute biggest pile of losers, idiots and true racists to populate his administration.
No time to dig up citations, but many people on the far right claim racial homogeneity is better because you have greater national unity. One big thing they miss is research showing that a diversity of races and cultures creates greater creativity and diversification. This definitely seems true to me. Having engineers from China, India, Europe,... really brings perspectives and creativity of a type you will not find in homogeneous cultures. And, I'm sure Noah can attest to this from his academic experience. Imagine the US without the 40% of Nobel Prize winners who are first generation immigrants, people like Albert Einstein and Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar.
Sounds like a load of crap to me. If any of that were true, how could China ever compete with its lack of the all important cultural diversity? Immigration and assimilation is an advantage in that it brings in more bodies and nothing more.
China has four times the population of the United States, and it still produces less Nobel prize winners and top line research, and I would say that the research does make sense to me. The United States is more creative. And China is also vastly poorer per capita. You really think the United States will be richer and stronger without people like Einstein and Oppenheimer? You really think we would be richer and stronger without all of those top engineers from India? Try thinking about it.
Chinese research culture is just bad. This is almost certainly related to Chinese culture being way more hierarchical than American culture. And that's not even getting into how the Communist Party can distort research priorities and inquiries.
Ethnic and especially racial diversity has nothing to with scientific discoveries. If it did why were almost all major advances post Scientific Revolution up to the 21st century made by European or American White men?
Diversity probably played a role in that competition between European countries stimulated innovation but racial diversity within those countries clearly didn't matter.
Hunt and Gauthier-Loiselle’s 2010 American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics paper, How Much Does Immigration Boost Innovation?, finds that college-educated immigrants patent at roughly twice the rate of college-educated native born Americans.
Their historical state-level analysis estimates that a one-percentage-point increase in college-educated immigrants’ share of the total population increases patents per capita by approximately 9–18%
An enormous amount of our scientific and technical advance came from Indian and Chinese scientists, engineers, economists, and managers, as well as contributions from Jews like Einstein and Von Neumann. We would be much poor and weaker without these people.
“The Contribution of High-Skilled Immigrants to Innovation in the United States”, currently listed as forthcoming in the American Economic Review, finds that immigrants constitute 16% of inventors but produce 23% of patents in its data.
There are pros and cons to diversity. If the ethnic groups are determined to kill each other and hate each other, and they don’t believe in democracy and human rights, then you just may have to separate them. But the United States at least used to be better than that. And if you are better than that, then you can benefit greatly by attracting the world‘s best, like all those top engineers and scientists from India, and you can really utilize their talents to make you richer, stronger, and safer, and you can actually enjoy other cultures. You can actually enjoy things like eating at Indian restaurants, or going to an Indian wedding, which is a fantastic time.
China has 56 different ethnic groups, although over 90% are Han, but the PRC practices diversification by stealing IP from lots of different countries.
There is some minor evidence for viewpoint diversity improving outcomes, but a) that is only weakly/indirectly tied to diversity in the race/ethnicity sense, and b) the benefit is statistically minimal.
The research on this from the last 15-20 years was wildly overstated. Shocking, I know.
Argentina, a country I know very well, is a great example of non-forced national identity creation. It has at least as many immigrants as the US, from all over the world, that have come in various waves. Yet everyone thinks of herself as Argentinian. They share a certain way of life and are very proud of their country but at the same time, in their homes, they also maintain their original culture and traditions. A German family will observe German traditions, an Italian family Italian ones, same for the English, Spanish, Syrian, Polish etc. Some more, some less, but when you get invited to people’s homes you see it very clearly. But it in no way conflicts with being an Argentinian as well.
Didn’t Argentinian football fans make a chant mocking the French team for having black players and implying they were not French? And then the actual team sang this song the next tournament when they weren’t even playing France?
"We both basically subscribe to the principle of nationalism — we believe that nation-states are exclusive clubs that exist for the benefit of their members, and that this is a basically good way to organize human society."
It should be stressed that any good family or club still cares about human beings outside of their group, and still treats them ethically and fairly, and still provides help to those less fortunate outside their group. Every good family I know donates some money or time or effort to help others in need outside the family.
And I should add that a family, or country, with friends and allies is much better off and more secure than one made in the image of Trump and his party, a hated bully, whose word means nothing, who can never have any true friends.
Amen Noah. I’m a conservative, but you are exactly right. Liberalism rightly understood is a big tent - traditional conservatives and liberals are always going to have policy disagreements, but we have far more in common than the rightists and far left that embrace different flavors of racial identitarianism. Keep up the good fight.
I don’t think we need a shared American ethnicity, what we need is a strong sense of shared American *citizenship*. The one basis on which we can unite our racially, ethnically, and religiously diverse country is around our shared membership in the civic identity of the United States, of equal citizenship under law. This is the umbrella under which all else is gathered.
We also need to rediscover a sense of what shared citizenship means. It means not treating each other as enemies even when we disagree. It means talking over and debating differences of opinion, a political process centered on negotiation and compromise, and a willingness to accept election results and policy outcomes that reflect the will of the majority even when you don’t personally agree. This is the way out of our current mess: remembering that we’re all in this together and we need to be good to each other.
What amazes me is how much all of this sounds just like Norman Tebbit's 1990 "cricket test" in the UK, and how it targets the same people. Back then, the idea was that British Indians who supported the Indian cricket team and not the England one were sufficiently not-integrated. Now you have something very similar-sounding with college football and whatnot in the US. In both cases, it suggests that the person making the argument just doesn't like Indians, and has no better reason not to like them than that.
It's all the more striking because, back then, British Indians were pretty well-integrated by most reasonable-sounding measures, like Indian-Americans are now. They spoke English well, had generally high educational and professional attainment, observed British laws, participated in electoral politics, and so forth. Those comments, like these ones, come across as goalpost-shifting with the specific intent of denying people access to your national, social, or political community.
Great column. And you're absolutely right that the Right will self-destruct as it tries to the country up by ethnic group, ironically the very thing that the Right accuses the Left of doing with DEI and arguments about white privilege. I guess this is an example of the Horseshoe Principle, where extremists on both sides of an issue increasingly resemble one another.
And I do have to wonder about the utter obliviousness of someone who's Jewish allying himself with neo-Nazis like Bo French to argue that people from India can't assimilate in the US. I mean, how long does he think it will be before these folks turn on him?
My mother, born in 1909 to German immigrants, didn't speak English till she went to school & was beaten up by native English speakers every time she opened her mouth. I know she knew German, but I never heard her speak it, & I never heard her parents speak German, either. I find that very sad. I live in a neighborhood full of immigrants from Central America, Nigeria, Eritrea, Ethiopia, & Vietnam, & every damn one is assimilating. Many are much more patriotic than I am, & I'm a VN war vet. It's sad to see fear & loathing of Indian Americans. We should do better.
My dad's family came over from Denmark after WWII, he grew up speaking English, Danish and German.
He can't speak either much at all now, and us kids didn't learn Danish or German. It's fine
Noah, I have talked about it before also but the absolute batshit insane dehumanizing rhetoric against Indians is tiring and so harmful for mental health (all social media is a cesspool of vitriol). This is also spilling over as hate crimes in various parts of the world. Even in your comment section I regularly see posters where supposedly reasonable criticism of India quickly slides into contempt and borderline racist (basically racism hidden as good PR)
The greatest irony here is that: Trump is turning out to be a great nation-builder for India. US’s great advantage has been its ability to attract the cream of crop from all over the world and then accumulating and compounding. Making those people feel permanently unwelcome is an amazing way to squander that advantage. And that is happening just as building a life and career in India is becoming an attractive proposition. Sure all industries still don’t pay equally but in tech already the reason to move to US right now considering all this is decreasing by the day. (And this should rejoice the racists). But other industries are also catching up.
I go to quite a few startup meet-ups and events in Bengaluru. Anecdotally speaking, I have met a lot of people in 20s and 30s who want to now stay and build, alongside people who are returning with experience, savings and professional networks. Those people are able to find co-founders, hire others and make starting more attractive for the next person.
On the infra side, India has been accumulating the foundations for this: highways and freight infrastructure, digital payments, a more integrated domestic market, and successive improvements to incorporation, approvals and taxation. Big reforms and hundreds of smaller changes gradually reinforce one another. For a growing cohort, there is now enough opportunity and capital at home to make staying a serious, ambitious choice. We’re entering a sustained period in which more of these pieces come together. We are also regularly posting growth rates north of 7% comfortably almost every quarter now.
The predictable response will be “Where are the results?” These things take years to emerge. My bet is that six or seven years from now, we’ll see significant companies whose founding teams came together here partly because staying or returning made more sense today.
There is real short-term pain for people whose opportunities are being closed off. But I’m increasingly optimistic about the long-term benefit for India. Racists will get fewer Indians arriving, while helping concentrate more talent, ambition and company-building here. US spent generations making itself the place where the world’s ambitious people wanted to build. India has every reason to make the most of America forgetting how valuable that was.
India’s capital markets are also deepening massively: mutual fund assets grew from ₹15.63T ($162B) in August 2016 to ₹87.08T ($900B) in August 2026, while automatic monthly contributions to mutual funds rose from ₹35B ($0.36B) to ₹323B ($3.34B) more than 9x, with all dollar equivalents at today’s exchange rate. Compared with China’s more state-directed allocation of credit, I think this growing role for household savings and commercially allocated capital is a more durable path. Sure, the Indian state cannot redirect enormous sums toward "state objectives" at the same speed. But deeper domestic investment pools give businesses more financing options and room to grow, with decisions spread across investors and institutions. Combined with improving infrastructure and talent staying back, I expect the effects of this accumulation to become increasingly visible sooner than many skeptics imagine.
Make America White Again is not going to happen, ever.
How many Europeans actually want to emigrate to America today? Few.
Most emigrants emigrate for opportunity; America provides that, but so do most European countries. What we should do is be more selective, but that selection should not be based on ethnicity, race, or religion.
Currently, the most successful emigrant groups are the South Asian people from India. They have skills and education. Because they carry the culture of education within them, their offspring will also be successful.
My family's primary care physician is Chinese, my allergist is Chinese, my cardiologist is Indian, a surgeon is Indian, my urologist is a white American, and my ophthalmologist is a white American. As you can see, mostly first- or second-generation immigrants.
Do you want to know why? If you walk through an urban coastal city's hospital, I guarantee you’ll see a slew of Asians and Indians. They are the ones who are willing to take Physics and Chemistry courses in college and are willing to go through schooling and training that can take up to 12 years. Americans are less and less willing to do so.
Take a look at the silicon valley CEO’s; you can smell the butter chicken masala just by reading their names.
This MAGA hatred of Indians is unfounded. America needs smart and hard-working immigrants.
The thinking that more Americans should study STEM and have more children is simply wishful thinking. We have become a lazy, stupid nation filled with nativists a dumb ass bubba’s who think we’re going to go back to the 1950s.
Actually, it is more likely we will end up as Britian, incapable of anything approaching its former greatness.
> We have become a lazy, stupid nation
Well, I don't think we're any more lazy than we used to be. And (being a computer programmer by profession) I suspect that the reason Americans don't take up STEM more is comparative advantage -- it's easier for someone growing up in China to get into a US college, study STEM, get a job here, and thrive at it that it is for them to study business, get an MBA, and get a job on Wall Street. The people growing up in this culture will tend to sort into jobs that reward cultural knowledge and fit. And certainly, here in the US we're really, really good at doing things that make money. (Whereas the UK's GDP/capita is barely growing.)
> Make America White Again is not going to happen, ever.
Heh! I just checked, and Google says the US population was about 20% black in 1776. And that was before the cotton gin, when cotton farming was unprofitable enough that the Founders thought that slavery would die out due to economic considerations.
Indeed, one way to undermine the ethonationalists is to point out that ethnonationalism is un-American. (A charge that will get under their skin.) The US has never been ethnically homogeneous, either in our terms or as people saw it at the time. And while the immigration laws have often barred specific ethnicities/nationalities, they've never been oriented toward allowing only a certain ethnicity to enter. For instance, during the tight immigration years 1920 to 1965, people from Africa were barred, but there were few restrictions on people from the Caribbean, no matter how dark-skinned. And while Chinese were blanket forbidden overall, Chinese who could cook Chinese styles were admitted as "workers with specialized skills". (There's a reason that Chinese restaurants became a cultural trend!)
True, but the American culture did not include different races. It was not socially or ethnically diverse. Funny enough the stories of slaves that ended up in Britian and became successful are legend
Overall agreed, but...
"How many Europeans actually want to emigrate to America today? Few."
I don't think that's true at all. I'm sure there are millions and millions of them. America is MUCH richer than most of Europe. Per Capita GDP is about 50% higher in America than Germany
Most immigrants in Europe would come from countries with a far higher social safety net. Sure, some Brits, a few Germans so Dutch. But to get the numbers that MAGA would like, it would take several hundred thousand. I just don’t think there are that many.
Most of America’s immigrants come here for opportunity that doesn’t exist in their country. But hey I am open to it. But that is not where we are going to find the numbers we need to offset the dramatic fall in birth rates.
I don't believe that immigration can solve the birthright problem at least not long term
Look at places like latin america, where most of the countries are down close to 1 for their fertility rate.
We need to take dramatic steps. Now to turn our fertility rate around before the cultural norm shifts too much
I would suggest greatly explaining the child tax credit
Building a lot of housing to drive down the cost of housing
And probably have the government pay for some pro family propaganda in hollywood And through influencers
As far as I can tell from the commentators, the number of people who migrate from Europe to the US is small, as is the number migrating the other way. Partly it's because the GDP/capita difference is compensated by the better safety net, but I think the major factor is that the GDP/capita ratio is only on the order of 2, and that's not enough to drive people to uproot themselves. But there are a lot of countries where the GDP/capita ratio is near 10... and even then, only a fairly small minority are willing to migrate.
"Do you want to know why? If you walk through an urban coastal city's hospital, **I guarantee you’ll see a slew of Asians and Indians**. They are the ones who are willing to take Physics and Chemistry courses in college and are willing to go through schooling and training that can take up to 12 years. Americans are less and less willing to do so."
I see a fellow watcher of Hasan Hates Ronny | Ronny Hates Hasan in the comments section here
Well Mr Musa, do you refute the observation I have made? I have no idea who Ronny is BTW, I am not a cave dwelling social media follower
Ronny Chieng and Hasan Minhaj from The Daily Show did a joint comedy tour earlier this year on AAPI sociology, and how the sociocultural divide between the Subcontinental diaspora and the diaspora from countries further east plays out in the US. Your observation on the heavy presence of 1st, 1.5, and 2nd gen Asian Americans (both East/Southeast and South) in healthcare is spot on, although depending on where in the US you are this also extends to their African counterparts.
During my last 10 years of work, I was a part-time paramedic in NJ. I retired about 4 years ago. I can safely say their observation is 100% spot on.
I seriously do not understand how they generate any controversy, but I also feel that way about Jews, and they seem to get the whole world hating them.
Increasingly hispanics in the US identify as "white", largely during a period in which purposeful ethnogenesis has been on the backburner.
Why? Ethnogenesis is a largely organic, not imposed process. As it was in the US for the Germans and Irish.
Coincidentally, the hispanic shift is also why the US will remain "majority white", a delicious irony for the New Right xenophobes.
They'll lose their minds when "Indian Americans" start considering themselves "white" too.
It's interesting to contrast all this with Canada. Canada didn't develop much of a "white" identity, perhaps because it's primary historical cleavage was (and arguably remains) language. Instead, the successful ethnogeneses are "Canadian" and "Quebecois". I believe this is why 2nd gen+ immigrants from India are more likely to identify as "Canadian" than "Indian Americans" identify as "American" (or "white").
Hispanics in the US identify as White because White-Hispanic intermarriage is extremely common. Many Hispanics (even very brown ones) are 1/8 or 1/4 European genetically.
You are correct that the Hispanic migration that right wingers hate is ironically what will keep the US majority Christian and White till at least 2100.
Some Indians like Nikki Haley look pretty White because they are 1/3 proto Indo European.
Though I've read that a considerable number of dark-skinned Indian-American kids are calling themselves black. Though my impression is that that is in fairly affluent places with low anti-black sentiment (and current pop culture can easily portray being black as cooler than being white). I don't know what American Blacks think of this...
First Kudos to Noah for taking on this issue by debating Lomez. It’s clear where Noah stands on this question, I just think that his framework leaves some important elements out.
First I found Noah’s conceding that Lomez favoring national cohesion despite his not being a liberal to be an odd concession to make. Conservatives and the far right have never been opposed to national cohesion, they just believe that certain groups need to be excluded from full participation in American society and civic life, or at the very least be marginalized to some degree, in order for national cohesion to be realized. Bo French isn’t anti-national cohesion. He just doesn’t see any path towards national cohesion that includes people of South Asian ancestry and culture, no matter how well they assimilate. And presumably Lomez agrees, he maybe just wouldn’t have gone public with a Tweet expressing his sentiments the way that French did.
And I also scratched my head a bit when Noah referred to Robeson’s song “Ballad for Americans.” It is indeed a beautiful song but to suggest that it reflected the mood of the time is inaccurate to say the least. Robeson himself would have his passport stripped away just a decade later, and in 1940 de jure segregation was still locked in place across the South and de facto segregation held in many other parts of the country. What Robeson represented was a tradition that went back to Douglass, Sumner, Stevens, and others which was an insistence that America live out the ideals laid out in the Declaration and other founding documents. It was an insistence that never chose to forget the past but also refused to be bound by it.
So if we’re to “Pick up the discarded project of our 20th century forebears,” it is indeed people like Robeson whom we should be invoking, but probably not so much FDR, Truman, and LBJ. Those three were reacting to agitation from people like Robeson, A Philip Randolph (who threatened a march on Washington in 1941 that led to FDR banning racial discrimination in defense industries and then a draft-resistance campaign in 1948 that helped push Truman to desegregate the military), and Rustin who organized the 1963 march on Washington.
I also wish Noah had pressed Lomez on his "hazing" framing. Second-generation Indian Americans aren't applicants, they're citizens by birth. Why should any citizen have to endure hazing to enjoy full citizenship? That same logic is behind the current push to reinterpret birthright citizenship, and I'd be curious whether Noah sees that as something to debate and compromise on, or something to reject outright.
So I agree with Noah that we need to continue and build on the incomplete work that our forebears started. But that requires us accurately remembering and understanding just what that work looked like, and why it was necessary.
The fact that Indians can have kids that are Americans is why America is the greatest country on earth. Love it or leave it!