70 Comments
User's avatar
earl king's avatar

Most of us on these pages are not Trump supporters. Anyone who considered voting for Harris had to ask whether continuing the Biden Administration for another four years would be good for them.

A slim majority of voters chose not to have the Biden Presidency continue. Many who voted for Trump were thinking they were going to get Trump’s first term. Whatever historians end up saying about Trump’s second term, I think we can say it has been nothing like his first term.

Trump’s kakistocracy seems more about enriching themselves, either metaphorically, as Pete Hegseth puffs himself up with push-ups, or literally, as Howard Lutnick’s wealth has risen. Remember, Lutnick’s kids and Trump’s kids have their names all over their crypto company.

Americans do not believe Canada is a threat to America. They are not as giddy about Trump’s renovations as his are and likely see it for what it is: a vanity project.

I agree with everything Noah has stated; as a conservative, I am a politically homeless voter. I often get stuck with awful choices, so I have to make a decision. Do I stick with my current Representative, a Republican, or vote for the lefty progressive Democrat with really dumb ideas?

Who is more dangerous, more damaging? This is not easy. My compliant Republican is not standing up for Conservative principles. He has no clue what Chesterton’s Fence is, and if he is he does nothing about it. If he is a conservative but is too worried about a Primary challenge to speak out, he is a political coward and not worthy of the position.

I want MAGA to enter the dustbin of history. It is dangerous, damaging, and deeply harmful to America and Americans. There is no making America white again. That boat sailed; Noah is spot on regarding Hispanics. They were a lifeline for the GOP, and Trump, with Stephen Miller, has pushed them away from the GOP for a very long time.

Trump and MAGA are more dangerous to the nation than any woke or socialist stupidity. If I end up voting for the lefty progressive despite her positions, I might have a stroke as I pull the lever.

Falous's avatar

[eta: stupid phone fat finger typos that bothered me]: In broad agreement, and indeed, even though I myself voted against Trump II as I didn't want to live through another Trump I of obnoxiousness, I also felt eh, Trump I was irritating and 6th January should have made the Republican Party put a knife in him out self-interest (I should hope many look [back] and see that long-term party interest means not blind Party firstism, but knowing when someone is clearly going to be a toxic liaibility (hello Trump) and push him under the [bus].

Democrats had a softer version of this with Biden.

and now we have the utter fiasco of ongoing national self-harm that is Trump.

I personally hold my nose and vote to punish the party that has most enabled Trump, the R one (not that the incompetence and bungling of the Ds isn't there too but in a world of binary choices...)

earl king's avatar

Its that binary thing that most pisses me off. The most extreme seem to run in primaries, giving us only choices of miscreants. My vote in Nov. may be for a Democrat, the typical Lefty Type you get in Blue States. I am in NJ. I haven’t voted for a Democrat since McGovern. I don’t even think he won his own state. LOL

Falous's avatar

Yeah well, we have the political structure we have* - have to be ready to punish even the party one normally favors, my old-school 'heritage**' New England Republican roots I don't love voting D but will do so and gotta be open to decent candiates outside of normal pref

The R party riding along with this T2 complete fiasco has incensed me. I can understand tolerating the vulgarism of T1 although I wasn't able to, but T2 is nothing but his scammy Queens mafia style profiteering, running up debt, tariffs, anti-free-market except for this cronies, whole shit that would have caused 'the party of Reagan' to have gone batshit....

(*by which I mean the system/legal structure, everything I have read says it's biaised in structure to this kind of set-up: without magical thinking it's based on reading on the stupid ass "primary reforms" pushed by the stary eyed Left of the 70s removed the ability of establishment to keep crazies off ballot and hijacking of party brand. Stupid naive Leftyism)

(**:(that heirtage shit makes me laugh, like I am an hierloom tomoto grown by one of my blue-hair cousin-aunties up in NH, fucking dopey).

earl king's avatar

The Heritage stuff is a dog whistle for white men who have issues with immigrants. But I also don’t discount your blue haired aunties. LOL

Pat H's avatar

I'd say there are also a number of politically homeless coming from the Dem side who have seen their party ignore pro business/growth ideas, who put identity over merit, who (like some of their GOP colleagues) have forgotten that a strong economy AND a fiscally sound government are key to our success and who haven't promoted an element of reform within the government (like Clinton/Gore did).

Trump 1.0 and 2.0 both suffered from a good ideas and awful solutions mindset, largely IMO from a degree of narcissism that they knew better than all the actual "professionals". And those awful solutions were frequently a result of over reach, with mass deportations being the classic example.

Can we not have leaders who are good at both problem identification with a solution to THAT problem without creating new problems. I think of George HW Bush and his approach to the freeing Kuwait (without invading Iraq) or even Trump's assassination of Sulamani (sp?) or the 12 day war against Iran in 2025...Be measured. Know/define your strategic goals and execute to those MEASURED/limited goals and STOP.

Had Trump JUST secured the border without over reaching with the mass deportation program. Had Trump JUST gotten rid of the E (in DEI) but allowed the D and I to live (not throw out the baby with the bath water to borrow an analogy) and not over reached by weaponizing DEI. Had Trump JUST had a strategy on trade that brought together allies to be a collective counterweight against china vs hundreds of bilateral negotiations with NO true/real defining framework and had Trump JUST used tariffs discriminately to support industries with a national security interest. Had Trump JUST had a modicum of relationship building skills to build a coalition to thwart Iran from the outset with lots of economic sanctions (and maybe also JUST a blockade from the outset). Had Trump JUST made NATO countries foot more of Ukraine's defense and applied again a modicum of sanctions on Russian Oil.....etc

But Trump is not about restraint. He loves to over reach to create division and attention. And 2.0 was not about hiring the best and brightest who were guardrails in 1.0 (as the best and the brightest had too much self respect to be a part of 2.0). 2.0 was NEVER going to be a success because guardrails (not just people, but IGs, institutions, etc) were a bug and were always going to be eliminated so that Trump could be Trump.

2.0 is and was always likely to be a failure because we are actually experiencing Trump as Trump (unadulterated) vs 1.0 of Trump with the guardrails of wisdom and restraint.

mathew's avatar

Excellent comment

So often trump with directionally, right About a problem, but his solution and or execution were always just awful

MDScot's avatar

One thing Trump still has going for him is the political ignorance of the majority of American voters. In our Substack bubble we know all the points made here but so so many folks have no interest in a diverse information stream. ( look at how many Texans had not heard of the remarks about the UT crowd) How many folks understand the crypto schemes, the deficit, etc? It is kind of fortunate for the long term stability of the nation that gas is high - most folks see that.

SM's avatar

This is something I hadn't realized until the 2016 election...most Americans don't know much about what's happening outside their community and social circle. They don't read the news other than to check on sports scores or celebrity gossip, and even then it's usually on social media. They don't fact-check. They don't talk about politics because it's depressing (fair). So a few days/weeks before election day, they just look at the ballot and go with their gut or which letter follows the candidate's name.

Shawn Willden's avatar

Indeed. What they do see, however, is the cost of a tank of gas -- or diesel! -- and the bill at the grocery store. To a lesser extent, they also see interest rates. When all of those spike, the party in power is going to have a bad time.

Falous's avatar

Humans are humans.

The mistake is a general one, notably of intellectuals who imagine our fancy abstractions and idealised models are actually real. And extrapolate our interests to what People Should Be.

Look back to the French Revolution and onwards, again and again this kind of mistake is made. Accepting mass people as they are is a step

Falous's avatar

People are people: most people are not political obsessives.

Ergo one has to work with that as one's baseline.

SM's avatar

It's very frustrating to see my Republican friends/family continue to stick with Trump. They all hate him now and wish he'd just shut up. But they continue to grudgingly support him and will vote for an R next to their name, even if they are very Trumpy. They don't necessarily agree with MAGA, but support them because of negative partisanship and tendency to take at face value any story that warns of a leftist takeover that will turn their community into Portlandia (but with more burning cars).

It was very difficult for me seeing them stand with Trump after Jan. 6 claiming that it was no different than the rioting that accompanied some BLM protests. (I live in DC and remember hearing the sirens and constantly hitting refresh on news sites/Twitter.) They continue to ask me how I can live in DC without catching a bullet. They say Trump is corrupt but so is everyone else ("he's a bastard but he's our bastard" I guess). Like you say, they don't like the inflation or the overt racism (though some have started to fiddle with it, and I've cut them off). They've started to become afraid of Islam (or rather afraid of Islam again, but it reminds me a bit of how they were under Obama...). They acknowledge that Trump's second term has been a lot worse than imagined, but cannot bring themselves to see that the other party comprises people other than Mamdani, Warren, and Sanders.

I hope that there are enough Republicans who are not like them and who will either vote for a moderate Democratic (if available) or not vote at all. Congress keeps chiseling away at its own power, but maybe a stronger opposition will finally push back on the executive branch more effectively. (I'm a bit pessimistic given the Dems' tendency to misread the popular mandate whenever they win it because their loudest members tend to be from dense cities where mainstream means something else than in the rest of the country.) That said, I expect the next two years to continue to be a disaster. Either the Republicans do better than imagine, and Trump feels like his policies are more popular than the polls suggest or there's a blue wave, and Trump thinks "fuck it" and goes down even more insane paths. If there's a blue wave, I also expect the more reasonable people with political futures, like Rubio, to leave the administration in the hopes of preserving their reputation for 2028. That just means more Hegseths and Bessents, which will not bode well for a stable and prosperous second half.

Robert Wilson's avatar

What’s really frustrating here is that the last two administrations have reinforced to Americans that their votes and views don’t matter. They hired Biden to be competent with COVID, dish out generous stimulus, and make our politics normal again. Instead, the progressives decided it was a great time to enact their wishlist of explicit racial discrimination in favor of minorities, attack the rich for being rich, leniency for crime, and open borders. People hated that so they fired them and went back to Trump to tamp down prices, get crime under control and sort out the border. Instead, the right decided it was a great time to enact their wishlist of explicit racial discrimination in favor of whites, attack the liberal world order, use military force to coerce opponents, and install personalist rule instead of constitutional democracy. People hate THAT so now etc etc etc. Through it all I think the American people have more and more lost faith in the idea anyone cares about what they want and instead the “elites” in Washington will play their game of thrones and take what they want and the rest of us deal with the consequences.

Brian Kirk Johnson's avatar

To run the same playbook from his first term, it would have helped to have fielded much the same team. But almost every prominent figure from Trump’s first administration — with the notable exceptions of Stephen Miller and Peter Navarro — declined to endorse him and many made it be known that they viewed him as an authoritarian who would critically degrade our democracy. So is it really all that surprising that we find ourselves where we now are?

Shawn Willden's avatar

Right, and the Project 2025 team was organized and prepared to step up. I don't think it's so much that Trump supported Project 2025 as that Project 2025 saw Trump as their vehicle, and he was happy to accept their adulation and assistance.

scott m's avatar

Excellent article, thanks. However, it would appear the real issue is not Trump, he is but a symptom. The GOP has gone alone with him every step of the way. The real agenda was never Trumps, it was Project 2025, and I don’t really see the GOP distancing itself from that.

Poah Ninion's avatar

I’m not sure that the insane tariffs/ personal obsessions with Greenland, Canada, his vanity projects etc./war with Iran was part of Project 2025 though

Marton Reti's avatar

I couldn't agree with you more on that it's slightly irritating how of all the issues with the Trump presidency, of which there are many, it's really mainly just the inflation question (even more so the price of gas actually) that is getting even Republicans pissed even though you would think that conservatives' love for the country would mean that they want a president and a government which symbolizes traditional American values and ways, which Trump and his cronies are lacking entirely.

NubbyShober's avatar

It's not just gas/diesel. But *everything* that runs on or is delivered by these fossil fuels. Which includes fertilizer.

Additionally, his gutting of USAID and Food Stamps has hurt the Farm States, because it was the purchase of US food products that these agencies funded.

Then there's the damage the tariffs did to US manufacturers, by raising both input costs--and financial certainty. The damage the deportation policy has done to construction and house-buying. The damage to US defense contractors by his threats of going to war with Canada and Denmark, that has caused the loss of up to a trillion dollars in business.

The suppression of the Epstein files, and the apparent failure to investigate the dead pedophile's income stream, hasn't exactly burnished the President's image.

But the Iran war takes the cake. He and Hegseth led us to war without any real planning. No minesweepers and anti-drone batteries prepositioned at our Gulf bases. No additional Carrier Group + convoy escorts (DE's & DD's) prepositioned in the Gulf. No crash stimulus of Patriot and THAAD manufacture in anticipation of extreme stockpile drawdowns. The real price tag of this conflict is possibly over $100 billion and counting.

If the Midterms are the massive Blue Wave predicted, it will at least mean a Dem Congress can begin to rein these morons in before he and his party completely destroys the economy.

Marton Reti's avatar

No, of course, you are totally right and there's way more to the story than higher gas/diesel prices but still, in reality there's nothing classic American about what Trump is doing, his very style and the gang he has built around him, the way he communicates himself and on behalf of the country, and already the way he kickstarted his presidency with hostility towards all the traditional allies while cozying up to the enemies should have been enough to make people, Republicans as well turn away from him, only for the douchebag image we has tainting the country with, but no, it had to be the economy that turned people against him

Kathleen Weber's avatar

Trump thinks a few smart, rich people should run the world. As far as he's concerned, everything is going according to plan. If you disagree, you're one of the stupid.

Falous's avatar

No, Trump thinks his Family and his Cronies. He has no broader concept of ideology. Not "smart rich people" - he gives no fucks about Bill Gates (e.g.) - he cares about Trump & Family (family as extension of himself) and his hangers on. Nada mas.

John Laver's avatar

My takeaway, on a positive note, American voters in the round are anti-war and pro prosperity on the basis of race-blind talent and merit.

The basis of Trump's failure is clear - he hasn't a clue how to devise policy that supports these aspirations. And the Progressive faction of the Democratic Party isn't much better.

(And if you were me, and lived in NYC from the '70's onward, you'd know Trump was a nasty, vain weasel with a morbidly, perverted moral imagination.)

Uwe's avatar

4 billion socked away already and he will never be held accountable for his crimes. 37% of the lower life forms still like him. We're only two years in and the authoritarian state capture will continue and expand. Only a fumble if you're thinking of a team player or anyone who isn't a psychopath.

Harold's avatar

Fabulous conclusion. Maybe Trump’s goal was to take the money and run. Making lots of money is success to Trump. Also getting praise, adulation and his name everywhere. But I think money is his prime motivator.

Flyover West's avatar

And to protect himself from further prosecution/being sent to jail. Noah missed that part.

mathew's avatar

Yes the prosecution of him made the presidency a must win

They either needed to not do it or do it in a quick manner to have it conclude before the election

Poah Ninion's avatar

Well the SuprMeme court kinda ruined the possibility of prosecuting him before the 2024 election with their immunity ruling that simultaneously was vague on what exact actions were immune, meaning a long and torturous process of running the charges against him through the courts was guaranteed even had Harris won and would have inevitably ended back up among the judges to finally explain which charges he was immune to after a few years delay

mathew's avatar

Actually, if you listen to advisory opinions, it was still possible to prosecute him for a bunch of stuff

And they actually updated the set of charges to be able to make them

The problem is that it was twenty twenty four

This should have been happening in twenty twenty one

They should have had a conviction by twenty twenty two or twenty twenty three at the latest.

If you were not a hundred percent sure that you could do that. Then don't bother

Shawn Willden's avatar

To Trump (and many wealthy people), money is the most indisputable form of praise.

Len Layton 🇨🇦🇦🇺🇺🇦's avatar

Any support for Trump proves that Americans are dumber than a box of hammers.

Matthew Lantz's avatar

“Between then and now, progressives massively overreached on race. They embraced explicit racial discrimination in hiring, promotion, and every other walk of life, in defiance of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and often of the 14th Amendment. Endless discussions of race, with guilt and “privilege” assigned collectively instead of to individuals, became standard in progressive circles.” Are the progressives running the Democratic Party? No. What’s the overreach then? It’s BS ginned up by the racist Republican Party and you fall for it hook, line, and sinker again and again. Who says The Civil Rights Act was defied? This racist, misogynist, bigoted Supreme Court? That’s not an actual reading of the intention of the law. You bend over so far backwards to appease Republican views that I’m afraid you’ll break your back at some point.

steve robertshaw's avatar

I guess Noah knows the majority of his readership likes to hear there's a both-sides defense to every Republican misdeed, even when you have to search the weeds of the internet to find a whataboutism. One side has full control of the State and the other side has a random House member or a city councilman with a twitter account, but presented as being equivalent.

JB from Napa's avatar

Looking back a hundred years from now, I expect that people will be stunned by the irony. In 2026, Herculean efforts by the small group of committed conservationists to protect the web of life on Earth were hugely boosted by card-carrying slime-ball Trump because his ill-conceived war with Iran greatly accelerated the shift to renewable energy. All this happened while 'smart' American liberals were fiddling with small-scale political questions as the planet burned, and American conservatives couldn't see past their immediate financial self interest. It seems life is indeed stranger than fiction. Perhaps we'll unwittingly stumble onto a better path in spite of ourselves.

Jim's avatar

My pet peeve about the Trump admin's "surprising competence in developing a vaccine": Competence would have been surprising, but I believe that's overly generous. Operation Warp Speed did something: it placed large advance orders and paid for manufacturing before approval. If throwing money at an issue is competence, then so be it, but the credit they deserve is pretty narrow. The underlying mRNA science came from decades of academic and NIH research. The first vaccine authorized was developed by BioNTech in Germany, and Pfizer declined federal R&D funding. Regulators worldwide used accelerated reviews. I don't remember anyone arguing for the normal 7 year vaccine approval process. Then the same administration missed its own goal of 20 million vaccinations by the end of 2020 by a wide margin. I'd call it a well-funded, well-branded procurement program. "Competent vaccine development" is overly generous.

Ed Hanley's avatar

Noah, I am offended by your assertion that Democrats generally have pursued racist policies by admitting to and acting to assuage collective guilt for sins against minorities. Yes, some "progressives" did and still do argue for this view, and like most Americans, we would admit to the sins of the past. However, I don't believe it has ever been a central part of the Democratic Party's platform or policy agenda to adopt racist policies as a corrective rebalancing program. I think it's more accurate to say this view is one embraced by a very loud fringe group of self-appointed "progressives" who chatter to one another, disrupt Democratic Party activities, drive GOP and other conservatives crazy, but in the end, seldom affect Party positions or elections. The "progressives" who have won Democratic Party primaries in the current election cycle generally have not featured the "collective guilt" theme, but instead have successfully argued for replacing leadership they view as too old, too comfortable, and ineffective in addressing Trump's outrages and the urgent economic issues affecting all but the super-rich. Either make an objective case for racist policies being a general Democratic theme or stop peddling Heritage Action's position.