Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eli's avatar

The "wonk gap" is here to stay, at least for a generation. The Republican Party has committed itself to a lot of ideas that repel smart people. Smart people can of course be religious or believe in American exceptionalism, but the Right has in my lifetime not *just* been committed to American exceptionalism and to Christianity but to the idea that it is *immoral to question or debate those views*, and *no* smart person could believe that.

The cultural Left is doing some damage to its credibility with some norms that insult people's intelligence, but the Right is in a really, really deep hole with smart millennials and Gen Z-ers, and all the issues with "wokeness" aren't nearly enough to help them climb out. No matter how angry I get at public employee unions or universities or the Sierra Club, I won't forget which ideological faction is more hospitable to the kind of person I am, and which spent my entire childhood trying to exclude people like me from civil society.

Expand full comment
Steve Lee's avatar

The Right’s economic plan is what the Kochs, Adelmans, and that up-and-comer Thiel want, which amounts to lobbying mostly for their very proximate business concerns (lower taxes, relaxed SEC and finance rules, etc.) and some pet economic policy fetishes (scuttling public transit or universal health care, various ‘libertarian’ stances like anti-labor and anti-credentialism, etc.). Not that the rank-and-file are paying much attention, where all roads lead back to cultural and racial grievance and authoritarian romanticism. Which, as it happens, does not lend itself to the wonk approach—ahistoricism is an intellectual dead end (hard to marshal facts and win Nobel Prizes in service of the Lost Cause and other historical mythology) and it’s hard to apply wonkish economic or other data-driven arguments against “Wokeism” and related boogeymen of current Right discourse.

Expand full comment
118 more comments...

No posts