Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nunzio's avatar

As someone who was deep in youtube in the mid 2010s there was a huge wave of anti sjw postgamer gate content at the time. It was definitely a thing and it exposed me and many other young people to a sort of proto alt right view point. But it was only a few years. Between algorithm changes and hype cycle changes it’s not been that way for a long time now. That stuff is still out there but as the research you posted suggests, it doesn’t have the same viral potential as it did in the past

Expand full comment
Joseph Conner Micallef's avatar

I think people pretty dramatically underrate how good the YouTube recommendation algorithm is. You'd have to watch a lot of radical content relative to other content for a day or so to even START getting recommendations, and even then you might get one video per refresh. The simple reality is that in order to get a bunch of radical videos recommended you have to 1) seek out those videos deliberately or 2) basically never use YouTube and wander into them.

The idea that you'll get recommended radical videos for simply watching innocuous videos on channels that have radical videos is similarly wild. The YouTube algorithm is really good! When I watch compilations of Seinfeld clips it knows EXACTLY what I am looking for and not only does not recommend any other content a clip-making channel may make it doesn't even recommend Seinfeld content that is not clips of the show! And the algorithm gets better the more you use YouTube. I would say at any given time that 90% of the videos in my recommended are things I would enjoy? Maybe more?

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts