This is a slam dunk situation for the Democrats but the only reason they will not be able to take full advantage of this situation is because they share the retarded beliefs of Bernie and AOC (it’s been a few days and not a peep from that socialist moron) and not in economic and social liberalism like classical liberals do. The country is fucked because the popular active politicians on both sides are complete idiots when it comes to economic policies. It’s up to centrists on both sides to blast both sides and bring the country back from the brink.
Yep. I worry that the free-market constituency is insignificant electorally. It's sad to me that, with all the hate on tariffs lately, no one attacks them from a simple liberty perspective.
??? Bernie and AOC are pretty much bog standard european-style social democrats. Are the governments of Northern Europe run by morons? They seem pretty fnctional.
More progressive income tax rates and national health care would not exactly turn the US into a dystopia, enacted 20 years ago they would have made Trump less likely.
No, they're not. Unlike the morons Bernie and AOC, European style social Democrats fund their national health care systems and other programs with heavy taxes on the middle class. If Democrats are willing to run on that and win, I may be personally against it but I'll accept it. The reason they keep talking about taxing the rich is because they know that taxing the middle class is a losing proposition. I personally don't want a national health care system because most national health care systems suck. Also, I would like US to be rich and not poor like most European countries.
Do you prefer US healthcare to French system? I am with you on the need to tax middle class to achieve that, but France seems to have way better system (and outcomes) than US.
There are tradeoffs but I would prefer the US healthcare system because of shorter wait times. When people are comparing outcomes, they usually mean life expectancy and life expectancy in the US is not worse because of health care. It's because of worse health, murders, car accidents & drug overdoses. None of those are fixed by a better healthcare system. I know that a lot of Americans think that life in EU is better but most immigrants from Asia, Africa and South America prefer moving to the US instead of EU. That should tell you something.
I'm sorry but your empty generalisations betray your ignorance of either the politics of Europe or the US. Do you think the idiosyncratic US health care system, or it's idiosyncratic laws for political campaign finance are to do with cultural preferences of US votes? Can you explain that? Can you explain how the popularity of Front Nationale in France is about something other than rightwing social and cultural preferences of a significant subset of the French public ?
Lol. That's not true. Except for issues like health care where the US is the single outlier like campaign finance or health care. To the extent that I don't think it makes sense to say these are 'rightwing' views.
Totally agree. Can anyone figure out how to be the party with 65-70% margins and not 51-49%? Centrists unite! You have nothing to lose but the wing-nuts in both parties.
This is dumb. Trump is in office because huge swaths of the electorate is unhappy with unrestricted free trade that doesn't have any corresponding benefit to workers who lose their jobs. Trump is an idiot, obviously, and his medicine is the equivalent of injecting bleach into your body. But that doesn't mean "become reflexive defenders of a bad status quo" is the right move, either.
Politically the right move is just to point out the bleach.
I think trade has been very beneficial to US citizens in terms of raising the standards of living and allowing the US economy to grow faster than EU. The average American is richer and leads a more luxurious lifestyle compared to the average European. Politically, the right move is to tax the large percentage of winners and pay off the small percentage of losers instead of lowering the standards of living for everyone.
I think Noah's position on this before today was a pretty good one. We need to use targeted trade restrictions and investments to rebuild some critical domestic industries, particularly semiconductors and energy. That's more or less what Biden was doing before Trump was elected, and Noah was very positive about it (in the past.) I worry that this nuanced language will devolve into some kind of "unrestricted pro-free-trade is always best" overreaction, and that this will be both bad policy *and* bad politics.
Unrestricted free trade is always the best, even though exceptions may need to be made for national security reasons. Protectionism for domestic industries is a pretty bad reason to add tariffs. There was no reason to add tariffs for EV cars, batteries and solar cells if you care about an abundance of green energy.
Agree again. The problem is that we have also made it too difficult and expensive to invest in infrastructure and housing to allow workers to relocate to faster growing regions. And our education system is geared to 4 year college and advanced graduates and not to vocational training for high paying technical jobs that could be the base for more small and large scale manufacturing. In other words, have a competitiveness strategy geared around jobs for the people who aren’t in the knowledge class, who are mostly low and middle class. Build more rungs in the economic ladder for the people and communities most impacted by lower wage competition from abroad.
So far, from my transatlantic point of view, I thought the unexpected quietness of the Dems was either due to a) leaderlessnes or b) the tactical reasoning to show people what they voted for.
Noah saying c) Dem sympathies for tariffs might be a part of it really came as a surprise.
The manufacturing unions are loving the tariffs. The policy is so obviously popular with the working class base the dems aspire to be representative of. Making liberal economic arguments about why taxes are bad for growth and growth is important etc etc is just not their comfort zone at all. They prepared speeches about why Trump cutting taxes was bad and are on the back foot now. They are accustomed to blasting Trump's vile racism/xenophobia/greed/whatever. Here, he is making a very well-intentioned policy mistake due to errors in economic reasoning. They are more focused on a handful of deportations of non-citizens that are awful, but insignificant to most Americans. They are similarly focused on DOGE spending and staffing cuts. They can't associate a bad intention with the tariffs like they can for the above things. They still think they can gain power by convincing voters Trump is a bad man. They would like to point to the increase in manufacturing employment under Biden, to suggest their approach was working and Trump is wrong, but there was no such increase. Oh well.
- Tariffs are not popular with the working class base, you think they are? Have you checked the polling lately?
- Taxes are bad for growth? (you think a nation with no taxes would succeed?)
- Trump imposes the biggest tax rise in history and that puts opposition politicians on their back foot?
- Trump isn't vile & racist & xenophobic & greedy? Those tiresome truth tellers.
- Trump's tariffs are well-intentioned? Well-intentioned economic warfare on our closest allies? Do tell.
- Those foolish do-gooders, so concerned that people are being disappeared without due process. Can't they wake up and see no one cares?
- Cancer research is gutted, scientific R&D cancelled, those silly people who think that matters.
- ("They can't associate a bad intention with the tariffs like they can for the above things.) Unintelligible.
- Straw man. Who thinks they can gain power by convincing people Trump is bad? No, we gain power because Trump is a disaster for the nation.
- Factory building and manufacturing capital investment were way up under Biden, the approach was working, you avoid this by making it all about manufacturing employment, which, by the way, was up under Biden. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MANEMP
Can you be any wronger? A bizaare mix of the obtuse and the untrue, and the spooky (sneering at those who care about the rule of law)
In the medium to long term, the detention and deporting of tourists and green card holders is going to have a far bigger effect on Americans than the tariffs.
Well, the lefties were right, the shock from opening to China was immense, though it followed a few decades of opening to Japan and Korea on autos, steel, and shipbuilding. The loss of old-line manufacturing jobs was severe, and most of those workers never recovered their (high, union-aided) incomes. The Democrats never really capitalized on that, largely because they had shifted their center of power to the knowledge workers, and the conflict with the working class on "social" issues was strong. But the Democrats are still intrinsically suspicious of markets and want to micro-manage the economy. Then again, that manufacturing proletariat class is shrinking steadily so it's not going to be a place to get lots of votes, however all this turns out.
Good point the Dem party doesn't really have a leader or demagogue to rally around like Trump has become for them the past decades. That is one reason messaging is all over the place, in addition to the fact that the current media environment isn't suited for long format takes.
I think you are cherry picking Dem comments a bit to build a narrative of Democrats missing the moment. The comments below counter that narrative.
Charles Schumer on April 3: "Donald Trump's tariffs are the largest tax hike on families since World War II. And of course markets are plunging. Donald Trump is singlehandedly tanking the markets."
Mark Kelly on April 3: "Trump claims that his auto tariffs will promote car manufacturing in America. Instead, people are losing their jobs, prices are going to skyrocket, and American families are going to foot the bill."
Mark Kelly on April 2: "Today is Donald Trump’s "Liberation Day." But what exactly is he liberating Americans from, our savings and 401Ks? His tariffs are going to be a giant tax on American families, raising the price of groceries, housing, cars, and so much more."
Amy Klobuchar on April 6: "The Trump tariff tax is the largest tax increase since 1968. It will increase costs by thousands of dollars per family. @SenSchumer and I introduced an amendment Friday night to rescind these taxes if the price of everyday goods increases.
Senate Republicans voted it down."
Also, am I dreaming, or didn't Kamala Harris hammer Trump repeatedly during the 2024 campaign about how American consumers would suffer economically if Trump's tariff proposals were implemented?
Once again Noah has identified the root cause of our problems...Democrats!
His headline is typical of his narrative. In it trump as the agency of fire!
Over and over Noah resolves the republicans and Magas of their responsibility and manages to blame Dems and libs for either causing the repubs to be they way they are, or not doing anything to stop them. It's Crazy.
"After this is all over, if Americans decide that “anti-neoliberalism” means tariffs, they will build effigies of Milton Friedman in their front yards."
Shouldn't that be idol instead of effigy, as in they would praise the figure, not burn it? 😛
Reshoring manufacturing to America assumes there’s a large cohort of unemployed workers with the fitness, skills and desire to work in factories. Is there? 18% of Americans are 65+. Meanwhile the median age in Vietnam is 33.
Skills and education? China STEM graduates exceed 3.57 million annually (40% of graduates).
U.S. graduates 584K STEM annually (20% of graduates).
Fitness? 40% of Americans are obese. Opioid addiction is rampant. And many cannot access or afford basic health care. US life expectancy is 77.5 years. Canada’s 81.3, Japan 84.5.
Highly paid unionized auto manufacturing jobs are the exception, not the rule. Bottom line: are Americans willing to work making shoes and garments for minimum wage?
Those demonstrations might have been cathartic, but I challenge you to identify a single coherent message coming out it--one which could actually give direction to action. What, "no kings!"? Sounds like a line from a Rush song and is just as empty and irrelevant to the moment. The Dems are simultaneously utterly directionless and spastic--a bad combination. "Do something!" is the politics of tantrum. Before they can *do* anything, in any kind of coherent and concentrated manner, they need to first figure out who they are--because they haven't a clue and, worse, the voting public doesn't either. To the average voter the Dems just look like a hodge-podge of deeply unpopular cultural and identitarian boutique issues.
"Trump is a bad leader who is hurting America" was the unifying message. Now his bad leadership is wiping out people's 401(k)s and soon it'll be taking away their jobs. At some level, when leadership is this bad you don't need a policy document, you don't *want* a policy document. You need a growing mass-movement that makes it obvious (to voters, Congress and other institutions in our society) that Trump isn't an all-powerful, scary, popular leader.
OWS raised awareness about wealth inequality but didn’t have a clear plan or any institutional support to address it. “Oppose and remove Trump from power because he’s hurting the country and might hurt you,” is a very clear plan and has gobs of institutional support.
Are you serious? What did you want? Riots? Some Djin to smack down stupid.
I am not a member of any organized political party. I am a Democrat. -Will Rogers
There were no rumbles in the streets. No rioting. That is what democracy looks like. Many had never been to a protest before. We are talking about people's livelihoods here, not Democrats vs. Republicans. For the record, I am a registered Republican. Though I didn't vote for stupid. Likely going to change that registration and join the disorganized. In fact, I will, as I type this, I resolve to make the trip to the commision today and change that.
"No Kings!" IS the message. The future leadership is undetermined but likely somewhere amid these protests. These tariffs are unlawful. These deportations are unlawful. The destruction of government agencies without congressional consent is unlawful. Impoundment is unlawful—a litany of unlawful acts are being perpetrated by an Executive gone, full-on King. Let's not start with the other unwise acts that endanger our future - defunding fundamental research that pays two dollars for every one dollar invested, and was vetted by the most vicious and competitive grant process in the world. Gone. Now forcing business leaders to restructure supply chains on a whim. No Kings! indeed. FDT.
If Chuck Schumer had stopped the continuing resolution, we might not have had to spend this past Saturday in the streets. You can't collect tariffs without Customs agents on the job. We might not have had to lose 10 Trillion dollars in capital assets. Just as likely, it would only have delayed the inevitable.
Change happens slowly sometimes. Other times, it is a tipping point. It is coming. The Democrats are blameless in this fire - Schumer made sure of that. The depths we are plumbing will call for a new remake of American policy and institutions. I hope the leaders rising sans Schumer and Sanders are up for the task.
Now, please excuse me while I go out and buy some dishes and underwear while I can.
No need to wait until 2026. Watch the Virginia governor's race; election is in November 2025. Abigail Spanberger is a moderate D, former US House member (didn't run for reelection to prepare 2025 race). She's strongly favored to win in this purple state. In prior election in 2021, over 3 MILLION votes cast. That's big. Plus DOGE layoffs have hit Virginia hard, putting elected Republicans in a bind: they fear Trump/Musk & MAGA voters, thus their response to laid-off constituents is weak (e.g., discounted adult education at the University of Virginia).
This is a good question. I don't know. One day at a time. I'm appreciating some that I had previously discounted. I'm not interested in individuals at this point. I just want a functioning economy and local fire department and hospital (the last of which depending largely on medicaid and medicare functioning as intended.) There's no joy in outing Democrats these days. Certainly there are no clear answers.
This seems like a mix of Democrats not commenting and Democrats not having adequate messaging platforms to comment with. Individual Democratic senators might have commented, but unless they have substantial personal social media followings they're shouting into the wind.
This is a self-inflicted problem to some extent. Part of being a politician in the modern era is building up your personal social media platform and farming engagement and living the influencer life. Information is heavily democratized now and Democrats have as many ways to get their message out as anyone.
But it's a real problem Democrats have and it makes this kind of thing much harder. Especially since institutions that would have served as key players in communicating the ideas of left-leaning elites (such as the mainstream media and universities) are all under direct assault from Trump for speaking out against the regime. Outside of actual campaign events, Democratic politicians have historically relied on these institutions to communicate their message indirectly, and now it's all being burned out from under them.
I do agree that Democrats aren't being nearly vocal enough with the platforms they do have, however. It really does feel like many of them aren't even trying.
The bigger problem Noah is identifying though is that several of the people with platforms are using them to try to claim that they are the real supporters of tariffs, and Trump is just doing them wrong.
I think Noah is right! But in a way, he almost understates the problem here. I think a lot of what's happening here is that we're now seeing the same dynamic with Democrats that we used to see with Republicans or businesspeople.
Imagine that you're a Democratic congressman with a few hundred social media followers. You can either post a milquetoast message about how Trump is bad and continue to have a few hundred followers, or you can post a controversial "Maybe Trump is right about some things" take and immediately be seen across national news for the controversy you'll create. Granted, a lot of the people will be spotlighting you as a source of hatred, but your follower count will shoot up and everyone will hear what you have to say. Whatever people think of what you said, you're now cemented in the public consciousness a Bold Truth Teller who goes against the grain.
This is a common dynamic with Trump. It's the dynamic that has allowed him to take over institution after institution. We live in an engagement-driven world, and he's so crazy that every individual in your institution always stands to farm the most engagement by finding a way to agree with him. It's a giant tragedy of the commons where agreeing with Trump becomes individually beneficial to their social media stats, their likes and follows. We've seen this happen previously with the Republican party, with the business community, and so on. Hundreds of reasonable people coming forward with engagement-farming posts. "Okay, I know he sounds crazy, but hear me out..." And one by one, the institutions fall.
This has proven to be an incredibly dangerous pattern for other institutions. It's a huge part of what's destroyed institution after institution, because it's very hard to fight against without top-down enforcement. You really need to have leadership that will call out what's happening and credibly punish defectors or this dynamic will shred your entire movement apart. It's why every organization that isn't explicitly anti-Trump drifts towards Trumpism over time.
Fighting this on a messaging level is going to require that the Democratic party accept a greater degree of top-down leadership than it has previously been willing to tolerate. It's not enough to hope that everyone organically opposes Trump and no one takes the bait - the incentive for individuals to defect is too great. People who defect don't even think they're defecting, they just think they're sticking to their beliefs and being bold truth-tellers.
The big question is whether the Democratic party is willing to accept getting their messaging from a top-down anti-fascist leader, and whether anyone is willing to step up and become that leader. Anything less, and we'll soon see a hundred Deluzio types tearing the coalition apart from within for their personal gain.
Curious… which institutions are you suggesting he is taking over? I can think of the three branches of government and Twitter. Are these what you had in mind, or are there others?
Yes. VAT. When I was in law school my tax law professor told me that Arch Conservatives (and he was pretty Conservative) hated VAT — not because it didn’t work, but because it was so easy to keep funding government operations, which drove them crazy. Maybe the Democrats can get on the VAT train and derail the Tariff Hindenburg?
Have you met a Democrat? The "No tax increases on anyone making less than $400k" party? The party that has been proposing crackpot tax ideas like unrealized capital gains taxes? The party that likes to imagine that corporate taxes are ultimately paid by corporations?
I think VAT is necessary given our deficit, I just see no path in which dems (or republicans) advocate for it. That would be a stunning reversal. I mean it would certainly feel like a betrayal if I had actually believed their incessant claims that we can and should fund their utopia by making the rich "pay their fair share".
One thing is certain, we are going to need higher taxes to wrestle down our debt. It's possible a modest Value Added Tax (VAT) might be legislated to help. However, VATs are regressive and there are many, many modest income American families who'd be hurt by them.
The reason the affluent and rich are better candidates for paying more in taxes is because as Willie Sutton, the colorful character who robbed banks said, it's “because that's where the money is”.
So, VAT isn’t crackpot? You just think it can’t be done? No one thought a President of the United States would levy a tariff on imports from an island inhabited by penguins. But there you have it.
Lately I've been reading so much left-of-center praise for free-market economics and I can't stop thinking, "where have you been all my life?".
Tarrifs seem like an amazing tool when you assume that the consumer isn't the one paying it. And de jure they are not the ones actually paying an import duty. The thinking is, foreign exporters, not wanting to pay the tariff, will invest in US manufacturing.
This is much like how Dems sell corporate tax increases. Make corporations pay their fare share. It's like a piggy bank to draw from.
Of course, both of the above taxes are incident mostly on consumers/workers.
Populism is about feel-good economic policies. Trump's dose of economic populism was a shot of adrenaline to the GOP. Dems like to message about the GOP only caring about tax cuts for billionaires. The tariffs are a hard one to spin. It's a big tax increase. It's cheered by working-class types and hated by the business class. The explicitly stated goals are to produce good middle-class jobs. The bad effects on the rich (via the stock market, for now) are being described as necessary, rather than as being coincidental or "just volatility". Trump is outflanking the left with economically illiterate feel-good crap.
I ended up getting into an argument with my wife and a friend at a bar. We were complaining about the tariffs, and Trump. I added that I thought there was a lot of blame to go around for this kind of rotten economic thinking. I pointed out Bernie's consistent stance against free trade. They said, no, Bernie just wanted more labor/environmental standards in trade deals. I replied that was nonsense, that Bernie considered outsourcing to "low wage countries" to be bad for American workers, which was definitionally an anti free-trade stance. They just could not accept that Trump's ideas were a recent import from the left, even if not the specific details (like using tariffs per se, as Noah points out).
It's sad for me that both parties are embracing industrial policy rather than free-market economics. Noah is a pretty free-markets guy that nonetheless is a big fan of IP. I think he let himself become a bit of a cheerleader for Biden's version of it at times, though. I didn't like Biden's industrial policy. Way too everything bagel and subsidies focused. They added even more regulations rather than trying to streamline. They put in all sorts of reqs like childcare, "paying area wages", and DEI, guaranteeing that resulting projects would never be cost competitive without subsidies. The pay-fors were highly inefficient corporate tax increases. They plowed money into regressive giveaways like student debt relief, destroying the fiscal air desperately needed for investment. Their anti-trust regime accepted making US firms less competitive globally, to extinguish their political power. Politics tends to make governments bad investors.
I would like to see a government boost industry through more efficient taxation (especially on capital investment deductions), targeted deregulation, mutually beneficial trade deals. Prove to me that you know what you are doing through those avenues, then we can talk about letting you spend some of my money on your subsidies plans. We started our IP push with subsides. Doesn't make a lot of sense to me when the underlying issue is structurally higher costs.
Isn't the issue that lots of people believe that "free-market economics" (in the Free World) is a good way to ensure that China becomes the world's only industrial power?
Yes it’s nuts to treat manufacturing as a jobs program in the context of a long-term structural labor shortage.
Noah’s concept is that you achieve productivity growth through investment leading to innovation. Productivity growth is the only way to produce more goods without producing less of other stuff people want (like childcare, healthcare, etc.)
The problem with protectionism, through this lense, is that we aren’t addressing productivity. We are trying to cajole manufacturing without a real productivity growth plan.
There would still be some domestic competition and productivity growth, but usually productivity growth is much better when firms must compete in export markets.
Progressives want to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. Not only are these tariffs disastrous policy, but Trump gifted the left by completely owning the choice and taking a single public action so that all voters will know who to blame. This isn’t a government shutdown where blame can be debated. The only thing the left could do to screw this up is to embrace the policy. Amen, Noah, for calling this out.
“Just throw tariffs under the bus, and spare the American people the college lecture about ideology.”
Absolutely true. The events of the past week show that the entire 30 year ''anti-neoliberalism'' tantrum on the left is just completely and totally intellectually bankrupt.
You're becoming the centrist parody of the Jacobin a bit.
For the Jacobin, every time Republicans did something bad, it was the Democrats fault for "letting them". Usually because the Democrats were squishy neoliberals.
For you, the Republicans are doing something bad and it's the Democrats fault because they have too much dislike for neoliberals.
Making stuff in authoritarian countries with near slave labor is bad actually. Demanding that products that come into America don't come from sweatshops that poison their workers isn't some radical Marxist take. (It's also orthogonal to tariffs which don't achieve that outcome)
It's also April of 2025. The midterms are November of 2026.
Even if the Democrats craft the perfect most viral message at the moment, it is probably too soon for it to help beyond the margins.
Noah didn't suggest Trump's tarrifs were Dems fault. He observed that they are failing to capture the moment, provided evidence of that, and then offered a theory as to why that is. You are confirming his theory by taking the view that free trade is actually bad, in defense of Dems.
Free trade is very broadly defined. If you buy a truck from Japan, that's free trade. If you buy a ton of cocoa beans produced by enslaved children in Guinea, that's also free trade. If you buy 45 kg of good Colombian white cocaine, that's also free trade.
If you object to some of those, that's fine. It means that Free Trade isn't a word with a limitless definition.
OK, but employing 10 year olds to make soccer balls is also illegal in the united states. Then Nike got in trouble for importing Pakistani soccer balls that were made that way.
Was making rules blocking trade made by child labor a "criminal" law or a "trade" one?
Hi, Noah! Chuck Grassley’s bill has a Democratic co-sponsor Maria Cantwell. Last week, Tim Kaine also introduced a resolution to block Trump’s tariffs on Canada that passed—to be fair four Republicans voted for it. Do you think this could be a case where Republicans seem to be leading the charge legislatively because their voices stick out more in our heads? It’s pretty unusual to see Republicans in Congress push back against Trump especially this immediately and openly. I wonder if this is a case where the Republicans aren’t actually leading the charge, but their actions are more memorable.
I think this is one of those instances where the mainstream Dems are trying to appeal to the leftists again. When there's a vote to repeal the tariffs there won't be a single Dem vote against. And Harris was right to shank the left in her presidential run. It's too bad that after the loss the party cannot seem to end it's fascination with these leftist imbeciles who know nothing about how economics works.
Almost nobody is being candid with the US public. Manufacturing jobs as we knew them in the 1970 to early 1980 period will not be returning regardless of the trade policies of Old Orange Head. Automation has made sure of that. AI may lead to a hollowing out of a lot of white-collar jobs which nobody wants to deal with right now.
While I would like to see the Dems more vocal on all these issues, they need to speak with candor and provide alternatives. I don't yet see a natural leader for this.
This is a slam dunk situation for the Democrats but the only reason they will not be able to take full advantage of this situation is because they share the retarded beliefs of Bernie and AOC (it’s been a few days and not a peep from that socialist moron) and not in economic and social liberalism like classical liberals do. The country is fucked because the popular active politicians on both sides are complete idiots when it comes to economic policies. It’s up to centrists on both sides to blast both sides and bring the country back from the brink.
The far wings of both parties are anti-liberal and hence anti-progress/abundance.
Yep. I worry that the free-market constituency is insignificant electorally. It's sad to me that, with all the hate on tariffs lately, no one attacks them from a simple liberty perspective.
??? Bernie and AOC are pretty much bog standard european-style social democrats. Are the governments of Northern Europe run by morons? They seem pretty fnctional.
More progressive income tax rates and national health care would not exactly turn the US into a dystopia, enacted 20 years ago they would have made Trump less likely.
No, they're not. Unlike the morons Bernie and AOC, European style social Democrats fund their national health care systems and other programs with heavy taxes on the middle class. If Democrats are willing to run on that and win, I may be personally against it but I'll accept it. The reason they keep talking about taxing the rich is because they know that taxing the middle class is a losing proposition. I personally don't want a national health care system because most national health care systems suck. Also, I would like US to be rich and not poor like most European countries.
Northern European countries are deeply wealthy and have entirely functioning health care systems
Do you prefer US healthcare to French system? I am with you on the need to tax middle class to achieve that, but France seems to have way better system (and outcomes) than US.
There are tradeoffs but I would prefer the US healthcare system because of shorter wait times. When people are comparing outcomes, they usually mean life expectancy and life expectancy in the US is not worse because of health care. It's because of worse health, murders, car accidents & drug overdoses. None of those are fixed by a better healthcare system. I know that a lot of Americans think that life in EU is better but most immigrants from Asia, Africa and South America prefer moving to the US instead of EU. That should tell you something.
You know - there is a massive difference between Germany or France and Albania when it comes to wealth. I am from EU btw
I’d say economically the evidence strongly suggests that Europe is run by morons.
Almost northern European polities end up governed by the centre right for the majority of time
I'm sorry but your empty generalisations betray your ignorance of either the politics of Europe or the US. Do you think the idiosyncratic US health care system, or it's idiosyncratic laws for political campaign finance are to do with cultural preferences of US votes? Can you explain that? Can you explain how the popularity of Front Nationale in France is about something other than rightwing social and cultural preferences of a significant subset of the French public ?
The center right in Northern Europe is left by US standards
Lol. That's not true. Except for issues like health care where the US is the single outlier like campaign finance or health care. To the extent that I don't think it makes sense to say these are 'rightwing' views.
Totally agree. Can anyone figure out how to be the party with 65-70% margins and not 51-49%? Centrists unite! You have nothing to lose but the wing-nuts in both parties.
Is There Nowhere To Hide?
What Is The Flight To Quality Safe Haven Asset this time around??
With the dollar weakening, it sure doesn't seem to be US Treasuries. Gold, maybe? Swiss bonds? Dutch, German, Korean, or Japanese bonds???
This is dumb. Trump is in office because huge swaths of the electorate is unhappy with unrestricted free trade that doesn't have any corresponding benefit to workers who lose their jobs. Trump is an idiot, obviously, and his medicine is the equivalent of injecting bleach into your body. But that doesn't mean "become reflexive defenders of a bad status quo" is the right move, either.
Politically the right move is just to point out the bleach.
I think trade has been very beneficial to US citizens in terms of raising the standards of living and allowing the US economy to grow faster than EU. The average American is richer and leads a more luxurious lifestyle compared to the average European. Politically, the right move is to tax the large percentage of winners and pay off the small percentage of losers instead of lowering the standards of living for everyone.
I think Noah's position on this before today was a pretty good one. We need to use targeted trade restrictions and investments to rebuild some critical domestic industries, particularly semiconductors and energy. That's more or less what Biden was doing before Trump was elected, and Noah was very positive about it (in the past.) I worry that this nuanced language will devolve into some kind of "unrestricted pro-free-trade is always best" overreaction, and that this will be both bad policy *and* bad politics.
Unrestricted free trade is always the best, even though exceptions may need to be made for national security reasons. Protectionism for domestic industries is a pretty bad reason to add tariffs. There was no reason to add tariffs for EV cars, batteries and solar cells if you care about an abundance of green energy.
Agree again. The problem is that we have also made it too difficult and expensive to invest in infrastructure and housing to allow workers to relocate to faster growing regions. And our education system is geared to 4 year college and advanced graduates and not to vocational training for high paying technical jobs that could be the base for more small and large scale manufacturing. In other words, have a competitiveness strategy geared around jobs for the people who aren’t in the knowledge class, who are mostly low and middle class. Build more rungs in the economic ladder for the people and communities most impacted by lower wage competition from abroad.
So far, from my transatlantic point of view, I thought the unexpected quietness of the Dems was either due to a) leaderlessnes or b) the tactical reasoning to show people what they voted for.
Noah saying c) Dem sympathies for tariffs might be a part of it really came as a surprise.
The manufacturing unions are loving the tariffs. The policy is so obviously popular with the working class base the dems aspire to be representative of. Making liberal economic arguments about why taxes are bad for growth and growth is important etc etc is just not their comfort zone at all. They prepared speeches about why Trump cutting taxes was bad and are on the back foot now. They are accustomed to blasting Trump's vile racism/xenophobia/greed/whatever. Here, he is making a very well-intentioned policy mistake due to errors in economic reasoning. They are more focused on a handful of deportations of non-citizens that are awful, but insignificant to most Americans. They are similarly focused on DOGE spending and staffing cuts. They can't associate a bad intention with the tariffs like they can for the above things. They still think they can gain power by convincing voters Trump is a bad man. They would like to point to the increase in manufacturing employment under Biden, to suggest their approach was working and Trump is wrong, but there was no such increase. Oh well.
- Tariffs are not popular with the working class base, you think they are? Have you checked the polling lately?
- Taxes are bad for growth? (you think a nation with no taxes would succeed?)
- Trump imposes the biggest tax rise in history and that puts opposition politicians on their back foot?
- Trump isn't vile & racist & xenophobic & greedy? Those tiresome truth tellers.
- Trump's tariffs are well-intentioned? Well-intentioned economic warfare on our closest allies? Do tell.
- Those foolish do-gooders, so concerned that people are being disappeared without due process. Can't they wake up and see no one cares?
- Cancer research is gutted, scientific R&D cancelled, those silly people who think that matters.
- ("They can't associate a bad intention with the tariffs like they can for the above things.) Unintelligible.
- Straw man. Who thinks they can gain power by convincing people Trump is bad? No, we gain power because Trump is a disaster for the nation.
- Factory building and manufacturing capital investment were way up under Biden, the approach was working, you avoid this by making it all about manufacturing employment, which, by the way, was up under Biden. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MANEMP
Can you be any wronger? A bizaare mix of the obtuse and the untrue, and the spooky (sneering at those who care about the rule of law)
I think you misread me in a lot of places because you think I am pro Trump, which I’m not.
I’m disappointed in democrats letting him win and not capitalizing on his missteps artfully.
I didnt assume you are pro-Trump, you strike me as more anti-anti-Trump.
In the medium to long term, the detention and deporting of tourists and green card holders is going to have a far bigger effect on Americans than the tariffs.
Well, the lefties were right, the shock from opening to China was immense, though it followed a few decades of opening to Japan and Korea on autos, steel, and shipbuilding. The loss of old-line manufacturing jobs was severe, and most of those workers never recovered their (high, union-aided) incomes. The Democrats never really capitalized on that, largely because they had shifted their center of power to the knowledge workers, and the conflict with the working class on "social" issues was strong. But the Democrats are still intrinsically suspicious of markets and want to micro-manage the economy. Then again, that manufacturing proletariat class is shrinking steadily so it's not going to be a place to get lots of votes, however all this turns out.
Bonaparte: "Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake"
Yes a combination of those
Good point the Dem party doesn't really have a leader or demagogue to rally around like Trump has become for them the past decades. That is one reason messaging is all over the place, in addition to the fact that the current media environment isn't suited for long format takes.
i sincerely hope it is b
I think you are cherry picking Dem comments a bit to build a narrative of Democrats missing the moment. The comments below counter that narrative.
Charles Schumer on April 3: "Donald Trump's tariffs are the largest tax hike on families since World War II. And of course markets are plunging. Donald Trump is singlehandedly tanking the markets."
Mark Kelly on April 3: "Trump claims that his auto tariffs will promote car manufacturing in America. Instead, people are losing their jobs, prices are going to skyrocket, and American families are going to foot the bill."
Mark Kelly on April 2: "Today is Donald Trump’s "Liberation Day." But what exactly is he liberating Americans from, our savings and 401Ks? His tariffs are going to be a giant tax on American families, raising the price of groceries, housing, cars, and so much more."
Amy Klobuchar on April 6: "The Trump tariff tax is the largest tax increase since 1968. It will increase costs by thousands of dollars per family. @SenSchumer and I introduced an amendment Friday night to rescind these taxes if the price of everyday goods increases.
Senate Republicans voted it down."
Also, am I dreaming, or didn't Kamala Harris hammer Trump repeatedly during the 2024 campaign about how American consumers would suffer economically if Trump's tariff proposals were implemented?
I agree. The predominant Democratic reaction is that Trump is nuts. Prices and unemployment will rise, the man is crazy.
Once again Noah has identified the root cause of our problems...Democrats!
His headline is typical of his narrative. In it trump as the agency of fire!
Over and over Noah resolves the republicans and Magas of their responsibility and manages to blame Dems and libs for either causing the repubs to be they way they are, or not doing anything to stop them. It's Crazy.
"After this is all over, if Americans decide that “anti-neoliberalism” means tariffs, they will build effigies of Milton Friedman in their front yards."
Shouldn't that be idol instead of effigy, as in they would praise the figure, not burn it? 😛
Well OK, OK 😊
No, an effigy is a model or sculpture of a person.
Burning or putting pins into one can make a rather striking point.
Reshoring manufacturing to America assumes there’s a large cohort of unemployed workers with the fitness, skills and desire to work in factories. Is there? 18% of Americans are 65+. Meanwhile the median age in Vietnam is 33.
Skills and education? China STEM graduates exceed 3.57 million annually (40% of graduates).
U.S. graduates 584K STEM annually (20% of graduates).
Fitness? 40% of Americans are obese. Opioid addiction is rampant. And many cannot access or afford basic health care. US life expectancy is 77.5 years. Canada’s 81.3, Japan 84.5.
Highly paid unionized auto manufacturing jobs are the exception, not the rule. Bottom line: are Americans willing to work making shoes and garments for minimum wage?
We are only two trading days into this and it's the Democrats fault? I don't think so. Were you in the streets Noah? I was.
The democratic response is coming in 2026. The Dinocrats may not lead that, I get it. But it is coming. No Kings!
Chuck and Bernie are about to get run over.
Those demonstrations might have been cathartic, but I challenge you to identify a single coherent message coming out it--one which could actually give direction to action. What, "no kings!"? Sounds like a line from a Rush song and is just as empty and irrelevant to the moment. The Dems are simultaneously utterly directionless and spastic--a bad combination. "Do something!" is the politics of tantrum. Before they can *do* anything, in any kind of coherent and concentrated manner, they need to first figure out who they are--because they haven't a clue and, worse, the voting public doesn't either. To the average voter the Dems just look like a hodge-podge of deeply unpopular cultural and identitarian boutique issues.
"Trump is a bad leader who is hurting America" was the unifying message. Now his bad leadership is wiping out people's 401(k)s and soon it'll be taking away their jobs. At some level, when leadership is this bad you don't need a policy document, you don't *want* a policy document. You need a growing mass-movement that makes it obvious (to voters, Congress and other institutions in our society) that Trump isn't an all-powerful, scary, popular leader.
Occupy Wall Street all over again?
OWS raised awareness about wealth inequality but didn’t have a clear plan or any institutional support to address it. “Oppose and remove Trump from power because he’s hurting the country and might hurt you,” is a very clear plan and has gobs of institutional support.
Fair enough; the situation is much simpler if all you want to do is get Congress to massively limit or remove his power to tariff.
aitch,
Are you serious? What did you want? Riots? Some Djin to smack down stupid.
I am not a member of any organized political party. I am a Democrat. -Will Rogers
There were no rumbles in the streets. No rioting. That is what democracy looks like. Many had never been to a protest before. We are talking about people's livelihoods here, not Democrats vs. Republicans. For the record, I am a registered Republican. Though I didn't vote for stupid. Likely going to change that registration and join the disorganized. In fact, I will, as I type this, I resolve to make the trip to the commision today and change that.
"No Kings!" IS the message. The future leadership is undetermined but likely somewhere amid these protests. These tariffs are unlawful. These deportations are unlawful. The destruction of government agencies without congressional consent is unlawful. Impoundment is unlawful—a litany of unlawful acts are being perpetrated by an Executive gone, full-on King. Let's not start with the other unwise acts that endanger our future - defunding fundamental research that pays two dollars for every one dollar invested, and was vetted by the most vicious and competitive grant process in the world. Gone. Now forcing business leaders to restructure supply chains on a whim. No Kings! indeed. FDT.
If Chuck Schumer had stopped the continuing resolution, we might not have had to spend this past Saturday in the streets. You can't collect tariffs without Customs agents on the job. We might not have had to lose 10 Trillion dollars in capital assets. Just as likely, it would only have delayed the inevitable.
Change happens slowly sometimes. Other times, it is a tipping point. It is coming. The Democrats are blameless in this fire - Schumer made sure of that. The depths we are plumbing will call for a new remake of American policy and institutions. I hope the leaders rising sans Schumer and Sanders are up for the task.
Now, please excuse me while I go out and buy some dishes and underwear while I can.
Everything is fine.
Tim
No need to wait until 2026. Watch the Virginia governor's race; election is in November 2025. Abigail Spanberger is a moderate D, former US House member (didn't run for reelection to prepare 2025 race). She's strongly favored to win in this purple state. In prior election in 2021, over 3 MILLION votes cast. That's big. Plus DOGE layoffs have hit Virginia hard, putting elected Republicans in a bind: they fear Trump/Musk & MAGA voters, thus their response to laid-off constituents is weak (e.g., discounted adult education at the University of Virginia).
Buzen,
This is a good question. I don't know. One day at a time. I'm appreciating some that I had previously discounted. I'm not interested in individuals at this point. I just want a functioning economy and local fire department and hospital (the last of which depending largely on medicaid and medicare functioning as intended.) There's no joy in outing Democrats these days. Certainly there are no clear answers.
Tim
This seems like a mix of Democrats not commenting and Democrats not having adequate messaging platforms to comment with. Individual Democratic senators might have commented, but unless they have substantial personal social media followings they're shouting into the wind.
This is a self-inflicted problem to some extent. Part of being a politician in the modern era is building up your personal social media platform and farming engagement and living the influencer life. Information is heavily democratized now and Democrats have as many ways to get their message out as anyone.
But it's a real problem Democrats have and it makes this kind of thing much harder. Especially since institutions that would have served as key players in communicating the ideas of left-leaning elites (such as the mainstream media and universities) are all under direct assault from Trump for speaking out against the regime. Outside of actual campaign events, Democratic politicians have historically relied on these institutions to communicate their message indirectly, and now it's all being burned out from under them.
I do agree that Democrats aren't being nearly vocal enough with the platforms they do have, however. It really does feel like many of them aren't even trying.
The bigger problem Noah is identifying though is that several of the people with platforms are using them to try to claim that they are the real supporters of tariffs, and Trump is just doing them wrong.
I think Noah is right! But in a way, he almost understates the problem here. I think a lot of what's happening here is that we're now seeing the same dynamic with Democrats that we used to see with Republicans or businesspeople.
Imagine that you're a Democratic congressman with a few hundred social media followers. You can either post a milquetoast message about how Trump is bad and continue to have a few hundred followers, or you can post a controversial "Maybe Trump is right about some things" take and immediately be seen across national news for the controversy you'll create. Granted, a lot of the people will be spotlighting you as a source of hatred, but your follower count will shoot up and everyone will hear what you have to say. Whatever people think of what you said, you're now cemented in the public consciousness a Bold Truth Teller who goes against the grain.
This is a common dynamic with Trump. It's the dynamic that has allowed him to take over institution after institution. We live in an engagement-driven world, and he's so crazy that every individual in your institution always stands to farm the most engagement by finding a way to agree with him. It's a giant tragedy of the commons where agreeing with Trump becomes individually beneficial to their social media stats, their likes and follows. We've seen this happen previously with the Republican party, with the business community, and so on. Hundreds of reasonable people coming forward with engagement-farming posts. "Okay, I know he sounds crazy, but hear me out..." And one by one, the institutions fall.
This has proven to be an incredibly dangerous pattern for other institutions. It's a huge part of what's destroyed institution after institution, because it's very hard to fight against without top-down enforcement. You really need to have leadership that will call out what's happening and credibly punish defectors or this dynamic will shred your entire movement apart. It's why every organization that isn't explicitly anti-Trump drifts towards Trumpism over time.
Fighting this on a messaging level is going to require that the Democratic party accept a greater degree of top-down leadership than it has previously been willing to tolerate. It's not enough to hope that everyone organically opposes Trump and no one takes the bait - the incentive for individuals to defect is too great. People who defect don't even think they're defecting, they just think they're sticking to their beliefs and being bold truth-tellers.
The big question is whether the Democratic party is willing to accept getting their messaging from a top-down anti-fascist leader, and whether anyone is willing to step up and become that leader. Anything less, and we'll soon see a hundred Deluzio types tearing the coalition apart from within for their personal gain.
Curious… which institutions are you suggesting he is taking over? I can think of the three branches of government and Twitter. Are these what you had in mind, or are there others?
This seems very right and important.
Noah: can you do a piece on GAT v Tariffs; and all this external/internal revenue sourcing nonsense I’m hearing Trump and the MAGAtudes yapping about.
And yes, the Democrats need a spine.
You mean VAT?
Yes. VAT. When I was in law school my tax law professor told me that Arch Conservatives (and he was pretty Conservative) hated VAT — not because it didn’t work, but because it was so easy to keep funding government operations, which drove them crazy. Maybe the Democrats can get on the VAT train and derail the Tariff Hindenburg?
Have you met a Democrat? The "No tax increases on anyone making less than $400k" party? The party that has been proposing crackpot tax ideas like unrealized capital gains taxes? The party that likes to imagine that corporate taxes are ultimately paid by corporations?
I think VAT is necessary given our deficit, I just see no path in which dems (or republicans) advocate for it. That would be a stunning reversal. I mean it would certainly feel like a betrayal if I had actually believed their incessant claims that we can and should fund their utopia by making the rich "pay their fair share".
One thing is certain, we are going to need higher taxes to wrestle down our debt. It's possible a modest Value Added Tax (VAT) might be legislated to help. However, VATs are regressive and there are many, many modest income American families who'd be hurt by them.
The reason the affluent and rich are better candidates for paying more in taxes is because as Willie Sutton, the colorful character who robbed banks said, it's “because that's where the money is”.
So, VAT isn’t crackpot? You just think it can’t be done? No one thought a President of the United States would levy a tariff on imports from an island inhabited by penguins. But there you have it.
Trump will keep calling it a tariff and the Dems can call him a bigger idiot for not knowing the difference.
This was a fire piece.
Lately I've been reading so much left-of-center praise for free-market economics and I can't stop thinking, "where have you been all my life?".
Tarrifs seem like an amazing tool when you assume that the consumer isn't the one paying it. And de jure they are not the ones actually paying an import duty. The thinking is, foreign exporters, not wanting to pay the tariff, will invest in US manufacturing.
This is much like how Dems sell corporate tax increases. Make corporations pay their fare share. It's like a piggy bank to draw from.
Of course, both of the above taxes are incident mostly on consumers/workers.
Populism is about feel-good economic policies. Trump's dose of economic populism was a shot of adrenaline to the GOP. Dems like to message about the GOP only caring about tax cuts for billionaires. The tariffs are a hard one to spin. It's a big tax increase. It's cheered by working-class types and hated by the business class. The explicitly stated goals are to produce good middle-class jobs. The bad effects on the rich (via the stock market, for now) are being described as necessary, rather than as being coincidental or "just volatility". Trump is outflanking the left with economically illiterate feel-good crap.
I ended up getting into an argument with my wife and a friend at a bar. We were complaining about the tariffs, and Trump. I added that I thought there was a lot of blame to go around for this kind of rotten economic thinking. I pointed out Bernie's consistent stance against free trade. They said, no, Bernie just wanted more labor/environmental standards in trade deals. I replied that was nonsense, that Bernie considered outsourcing to "low wage countries" to be bad for American workers, which was definitionally an anti free-trade stance. They just could not accept that Trump's ideas were a recent import from the left, even if not the specific details (like using tariffs per se, as Noah points out).
It's sad for me that both parties are embracing industrial policy rather than free-market economics. Noah is a pretty free-markets guy that nonetheless is a big fan of IP. I think he let himself become a bit of a cheerleader for Biden's version of it at times, though. I didn't like Biden's industrial policy. Way too everything bagel and subsidies focused. They added even more regulations rather than trying to streamline. They put in all sorts of reqs like childcare, "paying area wages", and DEI, guaranteeing that resulting projects would never be cost competitive without subsidies. The pay-fors were highly inefficient corporate tax increases. They plowed money into regressive giveaways like student debt relief, destroying the fiscal air desperately needed for investment. Their anti-trust regime accepted making US firms less competitive globally, to extinguish their political power. Politics tends to make governments bad investors.
I would like to see a government boost industry through more efficient taxation (especially on capital investment deductions), targeted deregulation, mutually beneficial trade deals. Prove to me that you know what you are doing through those avenues, then we can talk about letting you spend some of my money on your subsidies plans. We started our IP push with subsides. Doesn't make a lot of sense to me when the underlying issue is structurally higher costs.
Isn't the issue that lots of people believe that "free-market economics" (in the Free World) is a good way to ensure that China becomes the world's only industrial power?
Yes there is also a NatSec angle. Trump has emphasized the labor angle more. Noah is more focused on production than employment.
Given that we don't have mass unemployment (as we did a decade ago) it is folly to treat manufacturing like a jobs program.
Yes it’s nuts to treat manufacturing as a jobs program in the context of a long-term structural labor shortage.
Noah’s concept is that you achieve productivity growth through investment leading to innovation. Productivity growth is the only way to produce more goods without producing less of other stuff people want (like childcare, healthcare, etc.)
The problem with protectionism, through this lense, is that we aren’t addressing productivity. We are trying to cajole manufacturing without a real productivity growth plan.
There would still be some domestic competition and productivity growth, but usually productivity growth is much better when firms must compete in export markets.
I'd argue it's virtually always folly to treat it that way.
Progressives want to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. Not only are these tariffs disastrous policy, but Trump gifted the left by completely owning the choice and taking a single public action so that all voters will know who to blame. This isn’t a government shutdown where blame can be debated. The only thing the left could do to screw this up is to embrace the policy. Amen, Noah, for calling this out.
“Just throw tariffs under the bus, and spare the American people the college lecture about ideology.”
Absolutely true. The events of the past week show that the entire 30 year ''anti-neoliberalism'' tantrum on the left is just completely and totally intellectually bankrupt.
You're becoming the centrist parody of the Jacobin a bit.
For the Jacobin, every time Republicans did something bad, it was the Democrats fault for "letting them". Usually because the Democrats were squishy neoliberals.
For you, the Republicans are doing something bad and it's the Democrats fault because they have too much dislike for neoliberals.
Making stuff in authoritarian countries with near slave labor is bad actually. Demanding that products that come into America don't come from sweatshops that poison their workers isn't some radical Marxist take. (It's also orthogonal to tariffs which don't achieve that outcome)
It's also April of 2025. The midterms are November of 2026.
Even if the Democrats craft the perfect most viral message at the moment, it is probably too soon for it to help beyond the margins.
Noah didn't suggest Trump's tarrifs were Dems fault. He observed that they are failing to capture the moment, provided evidence of that, and then offered a theory as to why that is. You are confirming his theory by taking the view that free trade is actually bad, in defense of Dems.
Free trade is very broadly defined. If you buy a truck from Japan, that's free trade. If you buy a ton of cocoa beans produced by enslaved children in Guinea, that's also free trade. If you buy 45 kg of good Colombian white cocaine, that's also free trade.
If you object to some of those, that's fine. It means that Free Trade isn't a word with a limitless definition.
The last one is a bad example because it’s illegal to manufacture and sell cocaine in the US. It’s banned by criminal law, not trade agreements.
OK, but employing 10 year olds to make soccer balls is also illegal in the united states. Then Nike got in trouble for importing Pakistani soccer balls that were made that way.
Was making rules blocking trade made by child labor a "criminal" law or a "trade" one?
Hi, Noah! Chuck Grassley’s bill has a Democratic co-sponsor Maria Cantwell. Last week, Tim Kaine also introduced a resolution to block Trump’s tariffs on Canada that passed—to be fair four Republicans voted for it. Do you think this could be a case where Republicans seem to be leading the charge legislatively because their voices stick out more in our heads? It’s pretty unusual to see Republicans in Congress push back against Trump especially this immediately and openly. I wonder if this is a case where the Republicans aren’t actually leading the charge, but their actions are more memorable.
I think this is one of those instances where the mainstream Dems are trying to appeal to the leftists again. When there's a vote to repeal the tariffs there won't be a single Dem vote against. And Harris was right to shank the left in her presidential run. It's too bad that after the loss the party cannot seem to end it's fascination with these leftist imbeciles who know nothing about how economics works.
D's just need to point out that this is the largest tax increase in their lifetimes. Ignore where it is coming from. Rand Paul (!) got it.
Almost nobody is being candid with the US public. Manufacturing jobs as we knew them in the 1970 to early 1980 period will not be returning regardless of the trade policies of Old Orange Head. Automation has made sure of that. AI may lead to a hollowing out of a lot of white-collar jobs which nobody wants to deal with right now.
While I would like to see the Dems more vocal on all these issues, they need to speak with candor and provide alternatives. I don't yet see a natural leader for this.