Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JG's avatar

I’m currently in grad school studying policy, and I’ve been very involved in cash transfer research over the past 6 months. I too have been shocked by just how married Americans continue to be to the idea of “workfare.” Even my fairly progressive grandparents balked when I described the CTC to them - “but how do you make sure they’re not just spending it on whatever they want and not working?” Survey data backs this up - most people aren’t keen on the idea of just handing out money.

But I do think there’s still lots of “room for growth” in public opinion here. When normal people see the poverty alleviating effects of the CTC, they tend to be impressed. I’m a former cash aid skeptic who was converted by good arguments and data! I think people like readers of this blog should continue to champion these sorts of policies, and in another 5 or 10 years, we could see some real shifts in public opinion.

Expand full comment
Various's avatar

Very much like your post Noah. I often disagree with some of what you say, but I applaud your willingness to revisit your priors. We are all human after all, even the smartest amongst us. Inbound information is filtered through sometimes biased, sometimes ignorant filters, and we ourselves have our own limitations and biases, as we must. The healthiest amongst us is only on this planet for about 35,000 days, and our productive working lives are maybe half that much. Honest individuals do what they can to try to make the world a better place. Way to go.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts